That was horrible, it's fixed here:
Cheddarius - The reason I have had my vote on you all game is because you were switching your vote around so much - generally to whoever seemed like the easiest target.
Okay first I voted for TEM randomly, as instructed. So that doesn't seem suspicious to me.
Then I voted for Spitfire, because it seemed to me that he was being contrary to town strategy (voting to scumhunt) and instead using scum strategy (voting to lynch). Doesn't seem suspicious either, and how he's an easy target is not, to me, apparent.
Then I switched to you, my dear lad, because Toony told me to (sort of).
Then I voted Halmie because he was the only one to talk to, except he wasn't actually playing so ignore that.
Then I left the forum for quite a while.
When I came back, I found Siquo accusing me of lurking and such and it annoyed me, and also it seemed that he ignored my rebuttal which sounds a little scummy. So I voted him.
I have not voted anyone since.
The only person who I have voted who has been an "easy target" - having other votes - is Siquo, I think. So really, only 1/3... but if you could provide other examples I'll gladly discuss those.
Town results ARE 100% useless.
Why? You could be wrong on a townie being a townie and not a godfather, but the chances are slim. You may not know whether someone is a townie for sure, but you know that he's probably a townie (5/6, I think), and that to me is pretty useful.
I fail to see how that would be of any benefit to us.
Well, it's useful only if townie reports are useful - addressed above.
I still have a problem, guys - how can we get a decent copclaim without risking scumclaim too much?