UXLZ seems to be relaying out good info about from deadchat, but I can't trust that he isn't subtly changing a few people's names around. If UXLZ were scum, everything relayed from yesterday must have been good information otherwise none of the other players would respond today. Of course UXLZ might be transcribing everything correctly even if he's scum since none of the people in deadchat are correct.
Erm, so what actually makes me a scumpick? All you've really said is 'he may or may not be lying/transcribing deadchat stuff incorrectly.' Come on, you've gotta have something more concrete than 'he might be scum and
could be doing scummy things therefore he is a member of the scumteam.'
Even if your reason is 'gut feeling', please at least put that down.
Deus, Scripten, and UXLZ: Can you summarize your cases on ZU? I'm not sure I understand why he's getting the votes he is.
OMGUSing Scripten, general 'off' feeling, suspicious slot, OMGUSing
me ( at least it seems that way thus far, though without the vote), weird night action.
In addition, UXLZ: If you think Tiruin is so scummy, why aren't you voting her?
Where do I call her scummy? What makes you think I think she's more scummy than my current vote? The argument above us isn't me accusing Tiruin of being scum, it's just me arguing with her because she keeps insulting me and my scumhunting methods because she disagrees with them for personal reasons.
Who do you think are part of the scumteam? What's your opinion on Scripten thinking Tiruin was town yesterday and scum today? What are your thoughts on Persus?
Even on D4 it's pretty hard to pick an entire scumteam, especially given the lack of useful night-game we've had. I can give you my reads if you want, but asking me to name three people as definite scum is a bit much.
Erm... I have no thoughts? People's opinions are allowed to change due to new data, y'know. Especially given all the especially strange night-actions we had going on, I don't really see why his opinion on Tiruin changing is something to be considered suspicious. Is there a point where he's said something like 'I think you are scum because x', and is now saying instead 'I think you are town because x'?
Persus? Not sure, really. I'll have to look back over his posts to really decide, and I'm out of time now, so I'll do it tomorrow.
Another thing from Cheeetar. He also mentioned that he probably won't be active any more due to Uni starting up.
Oh- for what it's worth, my alignment detector is pointing me in the direction of Tiruin being town. This is pretty tonally based. Obviously she hasn't had as much activity as anybody else, nor has she made as many cases. From reading her posts and the PMs between us, however, I do think she's probably (?) town.
Cheeetar's leaning town for Tiruin, though I personally disagree with the idea of using 'tone' as a major measurement. Of course, Mrs Anecdotal Evidence herself will probably disagree with me, for personally biased reasons (though not necessarily incorrect ones). Tone is a fair enough basis for finding people to suspect but I disagree with using it as the sole factor by which to judge.