Only three votes on Tric... why does it feel like more? Probably because we have a few people indicating willingness to vote for Tric.
Mightymushroom:
Mostly the point any plans I had on Medium-ing secretly went out the window with this plan. I started poking as many holes into it as I could because it has workarounds that are obvious enough to see. Flowermaidens could for example dope to bypass the shield. I should know given I would have liked that role from the start. As is any longterm plans I had have been completely disrupted by this. On the bright side, that should apply to mafia as well, up till they use teamwork to get around it.
TricMagic I would feel better about you if you had more to say about this alternative "Medium-ing secretly". Anything you care tell me for starters, no use keeping it in if you can't do it any more.
I'm not sure I follow this line of attack. Can you expand on it please?
Webadict is reading fairly town to me at the moment, but I do want to know: is your vote on Tric based on anything but NQT's statement?
Juicebox: Now that the Plan for Night 1 is settling into place, what's your plan for the rest of D1?
Jim: Who do you suspect that isn't Tric or Egan?
Nirur:
How would giving Tric a shield help with the plan for tonight? NPCs cannot validate actions, nor do they need protection from mafia kills.
Just up the page, Toony proposed a change where you shield Wuba instead of Tric.
How do you not see the Tric case? He's an NPC bot doing random things, spreading chaos. This is only good for scum.
I'd love to lynch scum instead of an NPC bot. But a policy vote against someone for being absent, as he apologizes for his absence with a question to help bring him fully up-to-speed, doesn't strike me as working towards a town victory.
I saw the change after I typed that and didn't feel like changing it.
Every bit of what applies to Tric can be applied to Egan. What I'm not seeing is why Tric instead of Egan? Tric has more content that can be parsed, so any read-based reasoning can be outlined. It's all striking me as off, especially when you have people like Secretdorf blatantly looking for a bandwagon.
3 on Tric, 1 on Egan.
And then you
help him bandwagon. What say you, Nirur Torir? Why are you voting Mightymushroom instead of this policy bot lynch? Why are you ignoring Egan? Why are you helping zero-effort Secretdorf be zero effort?