Fun stuff.
Tolyk
One of the things that NQT might want to know is that he is about to die, at the end of the day, and I'm still not sure about saving him, though I'm leaning towards that.
When I read this earlier, I scanned past and just thought you were saying I was vote leader for the lynch and I didn't think much of it. Then I reread and saw what you were saying!
Good that you came in time, I guess.
Uh, how do you know this? Are you about to kill me?
I'd like a bit more information before I can decide what to do. If I know I'm about to die, then my town play will change: there's so much more I can tell town that won't be of any use to us once I'm dead, but if I'm going to live won't be in town's interests to share.
Well, technically, I poisoned you last night. I can save you today, and tomorrow, etc. though.
If I don't save you, you're going to die. This bypasses kill protections and such.
In light of recent events, though...
Read till the end, please.
TolyK
So since you were waiting on NQT - what can you say about this reply, huh.
Or this?
Back to my question - what were you hoping to see as a reaction from the guy as it seems like you're his hope of life and death and your cover story is proving him town or not.
Second post is just above. The first post:
If you knew Ranger was lying about knowing your ability names, why didn't you call him out?
Also, call it rolefishing all you want, but how many abilities do you have? If it's not three, why not call him out about knowing that too?
He'd already explained that he might have been given bogus names by Wuba, and because the name 'Cupid's Arrows' was very close to what the actual ability is called, I was willing to give him the benefit of the doubt on that point- especially as his information on the role (until he slipped up) was all correct. I've got three abilities, so that much was true.
apparently confirms that NQT was hoping that Ranger was completely town. The catch?
If they were both scum, then this was an EXCELLENT tactic, since it's just pretty damn illogical to know everything, and instead of (psuedo-)confirming NQT as town and his abilities, they make it into a meh-meh for BOTH of them.
If Ranger's town, and NQT's scum... then the only logical explanations would be that either Ranger was redirected or something, or Ranger is making things up (which would be silly to do here
). Not likely.
If Ranger's town, and NQT's town... then it all works good, except that Ranger lied, so we can't really trust him on anything.
If Ranger's scum, and NQT's town... this is the only part where you it doesn't necessarily end up good for town.
To get rid of the last thing, it might (might!) be a good idea to lynch Ranger. However, that gives us a 50% chance to lose town, but it practically confirms NQT's alignment, so I dunno. Up to you folks.
Tolyk: Am I correct in remembering that you said NQT is going to die today/tonight, but that you can stop it? If it's all true, I'd say go ahead and save him: he's got an (alleged) town inspect and (essentially) forfeited a daykill. This does not seem like something scum would do. What are your thoughts?
Of course it's not something scum would do, but the problem is nobody would ask "who wants to have a chat?" and do the traps and such, as well. So I have to consider the more outrageous possibilities as well.
I'm also thinking I'm going to save him, but I want to see what he thinks of the rest of this post.So... my theory is in the Ranger-NQT department (see above), the Vector-Zrk2-NQT department, and the Hapah-Toaster department.
Zrk2 was shown to be scum, so that lowers Vector's and NQT's likelihood of being scum. Vector is weakly-confirmed Town.
Toaster was actioned by Hapah to know his alignment (basically), though Hapah wanted to do a multiple-detect, so I'm inclined to believe him. That makes Toaster medium-confirmed Town, and Hapah weakly-confirmed Town.
That leaves Griffon, TWS, Tiruin, Zombie Urist and Me. I know that I'm town, though you don't need to believe me just yet, so I'll assume that.
We have a Scum and SK down, so at most 3 scum.
Given TWS and Tiruin, they got really distanced, so I am
inclined to believe they're different alignments, or both town. That leaves 2 of Griffon, ZU and me to be scum, unless off course one or both of NQT/Ranger are scum, which we can find out any ways. So, my likelihoods?
Name - Likely alignment (% chance scum - not statistical, but gut feeling)
Griffionday - Possible scum (50%)
Hapah - Probably town (10%)
notquitethere - Alignment checked by Ranger (40%)
RangerCado - Tied in with NQT (40%)
TheWetSheep - Tied in with Tiruin (35%)
Tiruin - Tied in with TWS (35%)
Toaster - Probably town (10%)
TolyK -
Vector - Likely town (20%)
zombie urist - Possible scum (50%)
That is 290% in total, so that's about right, considering I didn't give myself a percentage.
So.
NQT. You get me?
PPE'd by Tiruin. (Note: Looks like Tiruin's getting shocked that folks are quietly suspecting her, eh?
Mostly jk)