I don't have the presence of mind to work through all the possibilities these claims mean.
Sheep: I get that you think Tiruin is scum, but you're tunneling her excessively. Who else is scummy, and why?
I know. I need to get used to this. There's so many posts to go through looking for slips that I find myself sticking with what I already think.
Hmmm, my reads(All these claims are confusing me, but whatever):
Tiruin: Quite scummy. I don't think I really need to go over my reasons again. Recently, though, I'm getting a bit less suspicious of her. One thing that confuses me about my own case, though, is why Tiruin would lie about something like that. There just doesn't seem to be a benefit.
Zombie Urist: If Tiruin isn't scum then ZU probably is, seeing as he jumped on the Tiruin (bandwagon? Not sure if it was or not) soon enough. His favourite word seems to be "meh." I don't remember this kind of apathy from him in previous games I've read.
Griffionday: Town. Very good first game. Although I am wondering why he was so obsessed with cults for a bit.
NQT: I am really confused about him. Ranger says he's town, but I don't trust that too much given the fuzzy stuff around his claim. If TolyK's telling the truth, though, there's no point in lynching him.
Ranger: Also confusing. He did lie, true, but I had a pretty strong town read on him before and the way in which he presented the lie says town to me as well.
TolyK: Would say null, but I read some of his early D2 posts and they seem pretty town to me. Will have to look more.
Toaster: Confirmed town by Hapah, but if it weren't for that I'd be suspicious. The vote on Ford is one of the big reasons.
Hapah: Pretty null. Has a knack for flying under the radar, I think. I should probably take a closer look.
The Soldier: Null, due to no activity for a long time.
Other players are up for replacement.
On a reread, I found something that made me believe that Toaster and Hapah are not on the same team:
Hmm.
Tiruin, care to say "I am town" yourself? Hell, everyone should do so.
This doesn't seem to me to be a contrived way of showing that they're not on the same team. Seems pretty genuine to me. Although, of course, other powers might be at play, which leads to a question.
Hapah: How would a redirect of your truth power work?
Also, I dug up an interesting thing on ZU. His reads list:
Scum to town:
Tiruin
notquitethere
Toaster
Griffonday
Urist Imiknorris
RangerCado
TheWetSheep
Vector
Hapah
Null Reads:
The Soldier
TolyK
Zrk2
Correlates quite well to the votecount at the time:
Griffionday -
Hapah -
notquitethere - Urist Imiknorris, Vector, Toaster
RangerCado -
The Soldier -
TheWetSheep -
Tiruin - Zrk2, TheWetSheep, Zombie Urist(voted in the same post)
Toaster - Hapah,
TolyK -
Urist Imiknorris -
Vector -
zombie urist - Tiruin, Griffionday,
Zrk2 - RangerCado,
No Lynch -
Not Voting - TolyK, The Soldier
Despite not giving reasons for his reads, his top four scumpicks just happen to also be the four people with the most votes for them, excluding himself. Some sort of mass bandwagon going on here, maybe?
Wow, this post took a long time. I'll look for more, maybe get another post in later.