Lets see now.
-My flavour tells me that I am an ex-noble coffee merchant. Apparently, this village is on a shortcut. Given this, Urist's claimed backstory seems highly plausible. Based on this, I am marginally disinclined to accuse him of witchhood; it seems more likely that witches are locals.
-My flavour also tells me that the inquisition frequently wipes out entire villages, then blames it on the witches. It is possible that this is more of a bastard mod than we think, and there are, in fact, no actual witches. Perhaps there are only inquisition spies (falling under the wincon category of 'killers'). This is unlikely though; just throwing it out there.
-I am not sure about this Max lynch we got going on here. The crux of the argument appears to be 'fishing for flavour'; yet I pose that the only potential role information revealed is that of milllerhood, which is something that was revealed on purpose. In fact, I doubt that Max's efforts will yield any fruit, as all roles will probably have plenty of (virtually) irrelevant fluff, sufficient amounts to pass of as everything. Any actual information could easily be withheld. Unless the witches require this fluff for some reason (making straight asking for it incredibly stupid), there is probably no harm in it.
-I hate day1, always, forever.
-The web of suspicion and accusations is layered too thick for me to make head or tails of it; had I been there to witness it grow organically, I might have been able to pick up on scumminess. As it stands, I cannot make an educated decision as to who is scum. I will look things over again, but I may well not vote for anyone today.