Alright, here's my gut feeling chart right now.
Reads:
TricMagic - ...
80% Town: Yeah, this one's gonna come off as a surprise, but there's one good reason, and one mediocre reason. Claiming Miller is a Towntell. I'd even be willing to move this one up further because of that. I kinda want to, but it's not enough... Eh, whatever. I'm moving it up to 99%.
notquitethere - 90% Town: While I don't have a lot of notquitethere's scum performance, they seem to be on the level.
hector13 - 80% Town: I think they understood why what they were doing was bad. So far, they've given me no reason to not trust them. Also, they're defending me, a Townie, so that's automatic points, after voting for me. I felt like the reassessment made sense from my perspective, so I'm willing to defend them.
ToonyMan - 70% Town: I dunno, they don't really stand out as scum. So far, they've kinda been... I dunno, useful? Chillaxed? They seem very aloof, and that makes them too cool to lynch.
Secretdorf - 60% Town: Ehhhh... Loathe as I am to change my mind on them, they're not NOT useful, and they might not be scum. I kinda agree with Luckyowl on their assessment. Too noobish. But, being wrong isn't necessarily the same as being scum, and they've been active. Thus, they're at least a little Town.
Caz - 60% Town: Meh? Active but passive. Not really seeing too much issue, though. I kind of expect more, but that's just a little demanding.
SHAD0Wdump - Biased - Neutral: I don't like their cases, but I can't trust myself to make an unbiased assessment of them. So, we'll stick them here.
Toaster - 60% Non-Town: Eh, they haven't participated much yet, but... the little I've seen have been fairly minor posts that hasn't furthered any cases, but no real reasoning behind this other than gut feeling. Their three posts just don't give enough of a picture.
juicebox - 60% Non-Town: They haven't done anything, so it's not really fair to do this. And since they've done even less than Toaster, I'd be more willing to lynch them. But, too many people are going after them, and it's just an easy target.
Luckyowl - 60% Town, but not-trustable: I'd rather lynch them, just for safety. What's that? Read them as slightly Town and still lynchable? Git gud, kid.
Vector - 70% Non-Town: Vector... lied to me?
Something feels off about Vector, but I can't put a good reason behind it. They let me off too easily, and they aren't trying to find out my alignment. If they said their role was one that followed the same pattern, I'd have felt better, but they didn't... >:| Liar. And with them going after juicebox... I just don't know. I don't want to lynch Vector because I want to play with them too much, but if they're Mafia... I gotta do it.
PPE: I'm slow, and all these people posted. Meh.