I am just going to ask why NQT isn't participating in this at the moment.
Nin.
Superdorf, he had his vote on IcyTea early on. And yes, Max was cured of amnesia, otherwise, my nosiness wouldn't have pegged him as mafia.
Shakerag literally just stated Max's amnesia hadn't been cured. Also, why do you think NQT isn't participating right now.
RGU:If Maximum Spin was an amnesiac Mafioso, then wouldn't that mean that he didn't have access to the scum chat? While he was aware he was part of the scum, it doesn't mean the scum was aware he was also on their scum team.
If Maximum Spin was an amnesiac Mafioso and not a part of the scum team then that would mean that he did not have access to the scum chat. It would also mean that he would flip and inspect as town. Maximum Spin did not flip or inspect as town, he flipped as scum and inspected as scum. That means that he was on the scum team, which means that he did have access to the scum chat, which means the scum team should have been perfectly aware that he was on their team.
To be honest, the most likely reason I can think of for you arguing this so much is that you are in a scum chat and didn't see a message about Spin being on your team.
Kit: Can you answer the question that I asked you?
RGU:
I think you misunderstood what Shakerag said. I believe Macimum Spin started as scum, but was locked out of the mafiachat because of the amnesia, and thus his scum team didn't know he was scum and got him lynched.
And that's wrong. If Max was still an amnesiac, he wouldn't have flipped as scum, and if he was a mafioso, he would have had access to the scum chat.
Shakerag: If an amnesiac mafioso activates, does he gain access to the scumchat?
Yes.
Why do you care about this so much? Also, Max didn't even get lynched.
This is actually extremely infuriating to answer to, because you're both using assumptions I made based on what the mod said against me, even quoting the very same things I did, and I just can't see how could that make me scum or town if I wasn't even present when the lynch happened. Literally the only reason I'm arguing this is because Superdorf keeps pressuring me into explaining why I unvoted him, which is ridiculous by itself because if he's right about Maximum Spin then he's also even more scummy than before and I'll have to vote him again. Nothing of this makes sense to me and at this point we all should be asking the mod instead.
Shakerag: Can a player who began the game with the mafia alignment be absent from the scum chat? Does a player who started with an amnesiac Mafioso role know that they are mafia? If there is a player with an amnesiac Mafioso role, does the scum know they are? Was Macimum Spin cured of ammnesia at the start of Day 1? Would an amnesiac Mafioso flip as town or scum?
Well its also infuriating for me because you've continued to do nothing except argue some of your own assumptions, which are incorrect based on a bunch of information that is readily available in this thread. Half your mod questions were asked already, and this whole line of questioning has no point and is just filler that detracts from actual scumhunting, which I have yet to see you do any.
Aha!
Shakerag: Is it possible for someone to be an Amnesiac Mafia Role and still be Mafia at the start of the game?
Yes. (Took you guys long enough to figure that out)
I've been low-key arguing that this was the most likely scenario since it happened, for the record.
Proof for Mystery Green Goo: Mystery Mad Monk was a flip, and I dont remember a Mystery Mad Monk in The Big List
Okay. NQT, please daykill Kit (but not really, cause then we lose our daykill). Not only is there a Mystery Mad Monk on the big list, which you could easily find out if you use this nice web browser function called Control F (or Command F). But Mystery Green Goo IS NOT A POSSIBLE ROLE in the set up.
Eh, to be fair, NQT seems most likely scum just now.
So explain why he would daykill a Mafia member or fakeclaim doing so?
Author
Topic: Power Hungry Mafia 2 - Game over, SK team wins (Read 77615 times)