Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[hector13]

Mmm I would have to disagree with you there, Deathsword didn't have to vote for Scap.

Scap voting for Deathsword is more scummy, partly because it was only as a gut feeling, and it feels like an OMGUS too (as does Deathsword's vote on scap... double-OMGUS?)

[origamiscienceguy]

I realize that Deathsword didn't have to vote for him, but scapheap didn't seem to think that a fos is a commitment. A fos should be treated as a vote in this type of game. Except without the risk of a quick hammer.

[hector13]

This is true.

As I say, I think scap is scum. Could argue that DarkStar is his scumbuddy, given his early vote on Deathsword too, but I'm less sure of that.

[origamiscienceguy]

I politely ask Deathsword, Scapheap, and TheDarkStar to remove your votes and replace them with Fos's.

[scapheap]

I politely ask Deathsword, Scapheap, and TheDarkStar to remove your votes and replace them with Fos's.

I guess I did put him on the spot. Unvote.

Deathsword

[TheDarkStar]

I politely ask Deathsword, Scapheap, and TheDarkStar to remove your votes and replace them with Fos's.

Considering that DS is the one up for lynching, you're basically defending him. Why do you not want him lynched?

[hector13]

Are you sure Deathsword is scum? I'm certainly not.

[TheDarkStar]

Are you sure Deathsword is scum? I'm certainly not.

What are your reads right now, then? Do you think anyone is scummy?

[hector13]

Are you sure Deathsword is scum? I'm certainly not.

What are your reads right now, then? Do you think anyone is scummy?

Scap is most scummy, having voted for Deathsword as a result of a gut feeling that has no basis, followed by Deathsword with a slight scum lean, his vote for scapheap appeared a little OMGUS-y. DarkStar is next, quickly voting for Deathsword to make it L-1... not cool man.

Origami is exerting caution, which I'm cool with so far. I consider that to be a pro-town move given the game we're in. It's a slight read, though, for the moment.

What about you, DarkStar? Reads list + reasons, please.

[origamiscienceguy]

I politely ask Deathsword, Scapheap, and TheDarkStar to remove your votes and replace them with Fos's.

Considering that DS is the one up for lynching, you're basically defending him. Why do you not want him lynched?

I am not defending him. I am asking that the votes be turned into foses. This should be exactly like voting, it just eliminates the chance of a mafia getting a quick and easy hammer vote in.

[hector13]

You've not done much scumhunting so far Origami, do you not feel the need?

[origamiscienceguy]

Towards the end of the day, everybody should turn their foses into votes.

My reads so far:
Scummiest
ScapHeap:
You treat your gut feeling like it is omnipotent. After a bit, you took back your vote on deathsword as if to try to make the suspicion against you vanish.

TheDarkStar:

I politely ask Deathsword, Scapheap, and TheDarkStar to remove your votes and replace them with Fos's.

Considering that DS is the one up for lynching, you're basically defending him. Why do you not want him lynched?

You are a pretty experienced player. You should know that Fosing should be the same as voting, just without the implications. You also haven't undone your vote even though you are aware of the possible consequences.

Darksword:
Your quick vote on ScapHeap is pretty obvious. I am going to cut you some slack because you haven't been on since and you possibly didn't know the implications of a vote vs. a Fos

Hector13:
You seem very involved in scumhunting and your logic and analysis are sound.

Towniest

[origamiscienceguy]

You've not done much scumhunting so far Origami, do you not feel the need?

Sorry, you ninja'd me.

What do you define as "scumhunting" because two players can have completely different methods that still have the same amount of success.

[hector13]

Fair point.

You've asked a few questions then went into the mechanics of the game (town/mafia chances of winning and votes/FoS's) though you have been commenting on other players I s'pose... just attempting to start discourse.

I think my definition of scumhunting is asking questions, directly encouraging a player to react. You've asked some questions, but a lot of your other posts have been content-oriented in that your talking about what you think and why, which I could probably say is the next best thing.

[origamiscienceguy]

As you have probably noticed by now, I am not very good at analyzing emotional reactions. I am better at analyzing strategies and tactics of other players. That is my method of scumhunting I feel like I have done that a fair amount.

I do have a question for you though.

Hector13 Deathsword hasn't posted since his vote on Scapheap. What do you think about that?