Kansa: Sad to see you go. You gave it a good try, though, and it is good to see that you are still interested in Mafia. I hope to see you around here again soon.
PTDfun: Welcome to the game! After you read through the thread, please give your thoughts on the game so far, including reads of your fellow players. In addition, would you mind summarizing your previous Mafia experience, if any?
1. You only said I was scum now; your previous reason for voting was essentially a pressure vote where you asked me questions and reads. Why do you suddenly think I am scum now?
TheDarkStar:To answer your question...
I forgot to put an explicit statement of my read on you in. I shall correct that now: scum lean. My reasons are in my reads post.
What is it about bold red text followed by "TheDarkStar appears to be trying to give the impression of being here, but without actually saying anything of substance" that makes you only think "pressure vote"?
-I suspected buddying between borno and Ranger because Ranger was the only one defending borno for a while.
Huh? Can you give any example of this? The only defense of borno by RangerCado I can find is the one regarding that baseless accusation about RVS question writing style, and Ranger certainly wasn't alone in pointing out how poor that accusation was. After the tn5421 mess, Cado began his attack on borno, which clearly isn't a defense of borno.
Furthermore, did you have any reasons to lean towards borno being scum aside from RangerCado's actions?
Jack and Tiruin As the IC's I would like to see you two go head to head because it would be instructive and interesting. If one of you is scum then I would like to know sooner rather than later because later you will be rallying the town to attack itself because that's what good scum does.
LARD: You do realize that you can't just tell two people to attack each other, right?
If that is not an option, then at least answer this: What possible motives are there for killing tn5421 other than avoiding being blocked?
A few posts back, in a spoiler addressed to TheDarkStar (spoilers being a useful way to organize posts. Do read spoilers not addressed to you. It's worthwhile.), I listed a few of the many, many possibilities.
Perhaps because he was thought by several players to be town. Perhaps to cause chaos. Perhaps because he would be a difficult target to lynch and too risky to want anywhere near LYLO. I have little reason to lean strongly towards any one of those theories, or any other theory, at this time.
There are a lot of possibilities, and those are just a start.
6. No change, except for a bit more suspicious of you [TDS]. I don't use FoS, but if I did, you would have mine.
[...]
Also darkstar, I am very close to voting for you, so keep that in mind. It is a little threat, but I am still going after Kansa.
Why? What was it about TheDarkStar's actions after you posted your reads that made you more suspicious of him? About how strongly do you suspect him compared to Kansa/PTDfun?
One more question to you, LARD: Did Kansa's replacement request have any effect on your read of him? If so, what?
Was it a bandwagon vote to avoid suspicion?
RangerCado: I notice I missed this reaction test. The answer is no. Considering you didn't call me out for failing to answer this, I assume you didn't care much about this question?
MyOwnWorstEnemy: You're fine. I think prod demands themselves are often enough to get quiet players to speak, when said players are kind of watching the thread.