Sorry for double post... I didn't realize there are several pages of stuffs...
Fakeedit: Well, think posted while I was doing this, so no DP any more
Urist I: Do you think flavor will be a large part? If so, should we flavorclaim?
Tolyk, why do you ask someone else about what should you do?
... what? If I understand you correctly, you're implying that we *should* flavorclaim? Or are you implying that I'm asking what I'm supposed to do? Notice the plural "we"...
Tolyk: Would you take the pilots on their word about their claims? Why, or why not?
I would obviously take them with a grain, maybe even a spoonful, of salt. Because folks might think that pilot = don't lynch and don't kill, which it may or may not be true, and thus third party/unwanted factions might use that as cover-up. Also, as someone already mentioned, the dooplegangers might have a pilot of their own, even if the folks are telling the truth. There are too many unknowns and not enough equations.
IronyOwl, Flandre, Tolyk: If you were scumbuddies with vanilla roles, which one of you would you prefer execute the night kill? Why?
Uh... I'd likely be the most useless, so I'd expect them to figure out who to kill and for me to actually make the kill. That way if I'd be caught/whatever it would leave the better folks alive.
Bookthras:
IronyOwl, Flandre, Tolyk: If you were scumbuddies with vanilla roles, which one of you would you prefer execute the night kill? Why?
TolyK. He tends to be fairly lurky and useless, and while thus arguably ahead in some ways in RBing tendency, much less of a loss in the event of unexpected killing complications.
Yay, I'm lurky and useless... yfuck. I really got to work on that.
But basically what I said, so no worries.
IronyOwl, Flandre, Tolyk: If you were scumbuddies with vanilla roles, which one of you would you prefer execute the night kill? Why?
I would trust IronyOwl's judgement over both my own and that of TolyK's, due mostly to his experience and my lack of conviction in making burdensome decisions on my own.
Not the right question, who would *execute* it, as in do the actual action, not the planning.
I know very little about TolyK, so he does not really get my consideration.
And Tolyk, your low activity, nervous answers, and that one defusing smiley makes me uncomfortable. I would continue attacking, but I ran out of material.
... you're kidding me? I live in eastern Europe, so I can't be on at the same time as 3 pages of posts are made. And while agree that I use smileys too much (
) I don't see how that's bad in a mafia game, other than it makes me look less serious.
Nervous answers? Examples? Anything? You "ran out of material", when you said "nervous answers" without actually telling me which ones they were. Funny, huh?
ToonyMan, do you think that dooplegangers ("scum") are the main concern, or should we be looking out for whoever's following us?
Finding scum is important, however we need to figure out how the bastard works as well. Otherwise chance of (coherent) victory is slim.
Makes sense.
Unvote.
Just a note to all, I'm sick IRL, and this is the first day I've gotten better. I'll try to read through again paying attention to posts even without my name on them.