Dariush:Uh, that came out wrong. What I call chainlynching is Leaf finding four suspects, claiming that they are all scum together and lynching one, then going to the next without evaluating the changes that happened.
What made you say he was going to ignore anything and everything that happened in between?
Nuke:IronyOwl: Why are you voting MBP?
Because I think he's
RiAing obvscum who's openly admitted to killing Leafsnail to avoid being lynched
and because I don't particularly want my vote elsewhere at the moment.
But probably not scum. Because scum tend to think more about their actions and the consequences thereof.
Cool. What does the power of statistics say about who
is scum?
I am/was not voting because I did not have any serious suspicions.
It's D3. It's the
extension of D3. How can you not have any suspicions after two days of play, and how can you
justify not having any suspicions this far in?
MBP:Irony: You justify my that i am obvscum since i ''killed'' leafsnail, but if you knew you were town, had a kill and could kill someone not-confirmed in your place, what would you do ? Sit on your ass and wait a lynch?
Hm, good question.
Here's another one: If I knew that killing someone non-confirmed in my place would result in me getting lynched
also if he wasn't scum, what would I do? Sit on my ass and lose a townie, or wager
three townies on my kneejerk guess being right?
Hm.
There's also the question of why D1 you were all "screw you don't care not gonna do stuff this is normal you're tunneling scum," and then D2 you were all "OH GOD OH GOD LEAFSNAIL IS GOING TO KILL ME I JUST KNOW IT I WON'T SURVIVE ANOTHER DAY OH GOD THIS IS MY LAST CHANCE OH GOD GOTTA KILL HIM FIRST."
Bdthemag:Jim Im aware of that, I was just saying I would suspect that the Scum Partner would be doing one of those things. Im not saying that makes him innocent, thats just what I would expect scum to do at this point.
Cool, so he's not scum because your WIFOM tank calculations show he has a lower chance of that than normal. What do these vaunted methods say about who
is scum?
Jack:So, I misinterpreted your words. Oops. However, that fails to change the fact that you're twisting NUKE's words. A lot.
"Oops, I was twisting
your words. However, this isn't about me, it's about you."
How exactly is there a contradiction between "We probably shouldn't lynch someone who claims something valuable D1" and "Claiming doctor is extremely stupid"? I certainly see no contradiction.
There's a pretty obvious contradiction between "We shouldn't lynch someone who claims a valuable role" and "MPHGHPHGPH WHY WOULD YOU CLAIM A VALUABLE ROLE?" I notice you had to elaborate on Nuke's actual quotes quite a bit to make this logic work.
I see you turning a "We probably shouldn't take a big risk in lynching someone claiming something valuable D1" post into "Claiming something valuable D1 is a towntell".
More massive quote elaboration. He didn't explain
why we shouldn't lynch someone claiming something valuable in the slightest. I cannot fathom how the second part is hard to understand; if he doesn't want someone claiming something valuable killed, he obviously either thinks they're also town or likes scum power roles a lot. Hm.
I see you trying to turn a "WHY ARE YOU BEING SO STUPID" post into "Claiming doctor D1 is not a towntell", just to contradict your twisted version of the first statement.
That's because you're desperate to make Nuke's words look reasonable and good, and don't see why someone would have to be town just to want to specifically avoid lynching them. Why
is it that you have such insight into his plan, anyway?
And your first quote is utterly out of context, to the point of being an excellent example of quote mining. Looking at the first quote's context (a post arguing for a random lynch D1), he's not speaking in terms of towntells. He's saying that we shouldn't carry out a random lynch of someone who claims to be something valuable. His idea is stupid, in my opinion, but that doesn't change the fact that you're twisting his words to an absurd extent.
The quote was overly large, so I trimmed it. I fail to see how talking about randomlynching otherwise makes my basic townrole premise less valid. Was the point of randomlynching D1 to weed out boring roles or something? That's the only way I can see that not mattering.
Also, I love how I'm so clearly NUKE's scumbuddy that I'm not worth a vote or even a FoS. You're just trying to scare me away, Irony. I'm not impressed.
MBP's quicklynch is the only reason why I'm not voting for you, Irony.
If I'd voted or FoS'd you, you'd have called it an OMGUS. Since I didn't, you're calling me full of bluster. Can't win 'em all, I suppose, but I still think I avoided handing you the larger safety blanket.