-snip-
Smut is smut, and it's not something I usually expect to be particularly enlightened or insightful. I can disregard a lot of the fetish stuff that game entails too; the pornography market is big enough that I'm sure it's a challenge to stand out. However, I have a very low tolerance for rape, which is a current that permeates that game. And it's not rape as a horrible and traumatic thing either. It portrays rape as a just punishment. Rape as an act of revenge. Rape for fun.
Take a step back, and let that last one sink in.
I'm a fan of intimacy, up to and including sex, but... dude. It's supposed to be a mutual thing. A good experience you share with someone who is a willing participant. Never a weapon to embarrass or hurt someone else. Never something in which you exercise your power over another, against their will. That's twisting something awesome into something really and truly awful, and dehumanizing.
Yet that entire game is built around perpetrating increasingly reprehensible acts like that, lest they be done to you. Sex not as a good thing, but as adversarial and destructive. And worst of all, the author hides it behind this "The game is just sex-positive! Aren't you people sex-positive?" excuse. It's like he honestly buys into that "but it's not rape if it feels good!" bullshit.
And we can all agree that is bullshit, right?
So yeah. Smut is fine, sure. And outlandish smut-related fantasies about the aforementioned twenty-eight-inch schlongs and whatever can be fine, but... there are other things I don't feel it's healthy for people to fantasize about. Things like abuse and sexual exploitation. And that game just revels in them.