Actually Panda I made an argument against you and you never even replied...
See here:
http://www.bay12games.com/forum/index.php?topic=40671.msg728796#msg728796And my reply to forsaken1111
Lurking for 250 replies without even an explanation? Someone trying to avoid notice there?
I don't see how the first post of mine you quoted is suspicious. I say very clearly that I am unsure what Josh is, but that he could be either scum or town. I wasn't defending him or siding with him. Certainly it's obvious now that he was Scum, but at the time we didn't know. You're right that a fake roleclaim would have been suicide on Org's part, but I did explain why I was unsure about Org's roleclaim just a few posts above that. If Org had faked the roleclaim and gotten a town guardian lynched, dopps could have killed without fearing a guardian and Org would have been killed the next day. If he had a role like witch he'd have taken yet another townie down with him.
In that case the dopps would have lost 1 of theirs for 3 townies.
In any case, it was just a scenario and I was saying that I hadn't made up my mind. I didn't defend him and I'm glad he was taken out. The argument between myself and pandar was halfhearted because he never had a good case against me in the first place. I still don't really know what started him on that.
I haven't had the time to read through the whole thread hence the reason for missing a large portion of day1. As for why you are scummy with that post is that you are almost avoiding the CJ lynch, yes it *was* almost a forgone conclusion that CJ was scum, yet you were ignoring that or somehow missed it.
If Org was trying a gambit, it wouldn't be three townies lost to one scum... It would end up with Josh being lynched, a night kill that would have likely occurred regardless, and then Org being lynched. To me that is a loss of one scum for the death of a townie power role. That still isn't a good trade. I guess I see where you are coming from but I still feel a lynch of you is best for tomorrow when pandarsenic turns up scum due to the micro busing occurring between you two.
Another example:
Toony random voted Josh first post, redwarrior and forsaken immediately jumped on him with votes. I'd like to question you two a bit.
To both of you, who are your number one suspects aside from Josh (i'll assume) and why?
Well my 'jumping on' toony was a joke, I dislike his brand of crazy and prefer my own. I unvoted him shortly afterwards, you'll note.
To answer your question: My number one suspect would have been Vector due to his sudden aggression towards me for no real reason, but now I'd have to say Pandar as he was very quick to jump over to Josh. Methinks I see a dopp trying to blend in with the town at the expense of a comrade.
I could be wrong of course.
Author
Topic: Paranormal Mafia - Round 9 - Game Over (Read 69495 times)