Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Jim Groovester]

Everybody makes fun of me for wanting to play Noita,

but I haven't played any goddamn Noita since starting this game. :(

[A_Curious_Cat]

PPE:  Oh hey there's Curious_Cat.

Curious_Cat:  Can you clarify your case on Fallacy, please?

I'm not sure I can explain it better than in the post I linked to above (the one where I asked Fallacy and Tric some questions), but I basically think that lynching either Fallacy or Tric would provide a lot of information for the town to go on and, if Fallacy turned out to be a mis-lynch, the repercussions for the town would be less that if Tric were mis-lynched.

[Lenglon]

Everybody makes fun of me for wanting to play Noita,

but I haven't played any goddamn Noita since starting this game. :(

You could always give an actual response to my case against you if you want instead of a blank dismissal and then going silent like you have.

[Maximum Spin]

What even is Noita?

[Lenglon]

What even is Noita?

Swedish roguelike wizard game with truly custom spells that is designed to be broken and teaches metaphors about greed through gameplay. It's a ton of fun and recently started getting updates again after the dev team went silent for a couple years.

[FallacyofUrist]

What even is Noita?

A roguelike where you are a squishy wizard / alchemist and make your own spells by arranging spells in wands, with way too many secrets and extreme difficulty

Now give a reason for voting for me that isn't just meta stuff repeated ad nauseam

What even is Noita?

Swedish roguelike wizard game with truly custom spells that is designed to be broken and teaches metaphors about greed through gameplay. It's a ton of fun and recently started getting updates again after the dev team went silent for a couple years.

Yes, that.

[Toaster]

TOASTER'S CURRENT TIER LIST

Flailing Scum tier
FallacyofUrist

Scummy lurker tier
Knightwing
EuchreJack
NQT (Maybe? Even Scum NQT is usually active)

Lurker tier
Egan
Fluffe

Incomprehensible Tier
TricMagic

ERROR INSUFFICIENT DATA tier
Jimberly
Lenglon

Doing well enough for D1 tier
Maximum Spin
Juicebox... assuming they vote with logic
hector
ToonyMan

Town Tier
Curious_Cat


Well, I know who I need to read now, at least.

general PSA: I am a fan of Lynch-All-Lurkers policy-votes on day 1. As a reminder I started playing mafia during the extend-spam phase of the forum, and saw many games die from inactivity and saw many scum wins through silence. I am 180% willing to swap off of a day 1 (specifically day 1) lynch case to a policy-vote.

Who's your current pick for said lurker lynch?  Why?

Knightwing, followed by NQT and Jack. Knightwing is especially a problem because IIRC knightwing is normally highly active. NQT is next because although NQT normal meta is low-activity for most of D1, he does normally step it up as we near day end. By day's end I expect him to have analysis of D1 as a whole for us, and if it doesn't show then it'll be quite odd. Jack's last only because the other two stand out so much as problems, and I don't have a feel for Jack's meta so I don't know what standard to expect. All three are currently acceptable to me.

Okay.

[A_Curious_Cat]

No one's going to tell me what "managing town" means?

[Lenglon]

No one's going to tell me what "managing town" means?

You should ask Max and Jim specifically. They're the ones using it in their arguments and they wouldn't agree with my summary of it.

[Toaster]

No one's going to tell me what "managing town" means?

Not really a phrase I use, but the best example I can give is right here in thread where Fallacy is proposing a plan and trying to get everyone to go along.  At least in my opinion.

[FallacyofUrist]

Yeah, this case has exhausted its usefulness. Since there's no way it actually goes through unless Tric makes the scum slip of a lifetime, unvote.

No one's going to tell me what "managing town" means?

Not really a phrase I use, but the best example I can give is right here in thread where Fallacy is proposing a plan and trying to get everyone to go along.  At least in my opinion.

But that's something players of all alignments do...

[Maximum Spin]

No one's going to tell me what "managing town" means?

Not really a phrase I use, but the best example I can give is right here in thread where Fallacy is proposing a plan and trying to get everyone to go along.  At least in my opinion.

Can confirm.
The first half of the post is also managing town - telling everyone what "the question" should be and then telling everyone what to think about that instead of giving a real reads list.

[Toaster]

Oh yeah; error correction.

NQT:  Actually don't much like NQT so far.  NQT loves to throw big walls of text with in depth arguments.  Instead we see three weak votes.  Not happy with NQT's content at all.

Upon further review, I'm pretty sure that first vote on juicebox is an RVS vote.  That doesn't really affect my read on him, but I wanted to correct myself.


Fallacy:

Yeah, this case has exhausted its usefulness. Since there's no way it actually goes through unless Tric makes the scum slip of a lifetime, unvote.

No one's going to tell me what "managing town" means?

Not really a phrase I use, but the best example I can give is right here in thread where Fallacy is proposing a plan and trying to get everyone to go along.  At least in my opinion.

But that's something players of all alignments do...

I did say it's not something I use.

[FallacyofUrist]

I didn't say it's something everyone uses, I said it's something all alignments use. Townies want cooperative townies and scum want cooperative townies.

[Lenglon]

FoU, Toaster said it's a phrase they don't use. You're arguing with people that agree with you that it's a nulltell.