I'm dead but I get to make one game related post so this is it.
Firstly, you guys need to post more.
Secondly, my reads:
EuchreJack - Nightmare
KittyTac - Null
notquitethere - lean very mildly Friend
TricMagic - lean mildly Friend
BluearianKnight - lean Friend
I don't know if it's relevant but I had the badger mask.
If the Best Friend dies you need to hammer the Nightmare that phase because you won't know if the Nightmare targeted the Dreamer and hence knows who the Dreamer is and has queued up the kill on the Dreamer for the next shot.
"Putting the votes in hammer range is really dangerous if we haven't figured out the nightmare because if they've figured out the dreamer we all lose"
This works both ways, you know? Its as much a threat for the Nightmare as it is for the Dreamer, all around. Why don't you want us to put the vote within hammer range?
Also, please vote. It would clear up some things.
Yes I truly believe that when you ask people to vote it is coming from a place where you are truly interested in finding the Nightmare.
Also I like how you urge people to vote without voting yourself as if you need other people's cases to sheep.
Which is exactly what you did when notquitethere cast his vote.
Reading the sparse if informative commentary, I'd place two people as scum. Only one of them is though, so I'll withhold for now until the nightmare has killed. It should become rather obvious if the nightmare makes to mistake of killing the other suspect.
Following that line of logic, if TricMagic were the Nightmare, they would kill Jim Groovester to throw the blame on me, the only one that was being voted on.
Since I'm NOT the Nightmare, I'm going to assume that TricMagic has revealed themselves to be the Nightmare and vote accordingly.
If there are flaws in my logic, please let me know.
TricMagic
There are a couple. The first is assuming you can read anything from the kill at all. The second is assuming that TricMagic alone would kill me to throw suspicion onto you, which is hardly meaningful since there could be several players who would do that.
You do know that if you hammer TricMagic and he's not the Dreamer, you lose, right?
PPE: okay it's down to five. It's safer to vote now:
TricMagic
Why is it safer to vote at five when it takes only three people for the Dreamer or the Nightmare to hammer compared to when there was six and it took four votes?
Put simply, my reads are Jack and NQT. How nice to kill the one voting you jack. Granted, NQT would do it too, so one of you two are the nightmare.
Based on the spoiler which quote put me onto you in the first place, I believe NQT is the Nightmare.
This doesn't make any sense so I can only assume TricMagic is not scum.
Anyways, good luck, Friends.