Locate Eldritch Victim and...
...If pressed, insist scarf was a drunken hallucination all along: +2, maybe +3
...Upon catching up with the one who got stolen from, ask if the scarves worn by the thieves were green: +1
...Chase the mousie before it gets away!: +1
Question ourselves, as we now know we where actually a member of the gang all along!: +2
Inspect companions for scarves.: +1
We could tail the victim, maybe he’ll be stolen from again and we’ll see who’s stealing from him, maybe it’s the Green Scarves. We could also travel with him and watch for any thievery attempts: +1
You stow your scarf away in your pack and run out to locate the most promising witness so far. Luckily, it doesn't take too long to find an elderly mouse wearing a coat of many pockets. You wave down the Eldritch Victim near a particularly dark alley, pluck out a feather, and take out a small stack of parchment. Completely unrelated to this, the world suddenly seems to be drained of color and light, and it begins to rain on these mean streets.
"Who...who are you and what do you want?"
"Detective Chook Chickensworth, at your service. I'm here about the pickpocketing. Suppose you could tell me more about it?"
"It was horrible! I was walking home after an evening at the tavern when a gang of scarved ruffians ran out of a dark alley! They bumped into me while I valiantly shouted them down, and when they ran away like the cowards they were, my holy book and most of my money were missing!"
"Day and time?"
"Yesterday after the bar closed."
"Place?"
"Between Apeman and Forest on Market."
"And this gang of ruffians, were their scarves green?"
"
I don't know. I'm not
one of you birdbr--er, birds or a reptile or an ape. It was too dark anyway. All I know is they all wore scarves, and hardly anyone around here does in summer."
"Mind telling me more about the thieves?"
"One of them flew. The other two ran."
"Anyone else I can talk to about this pickpocketing?"
"Streets were empty, and curfew was in place. 'Only covered or cold lanterns' and all that."
"Thank you, Mr. Victim. You've been very helpful to this investigation."
"WHAT DID YOU JUST CALL ME?"
You walk away the now curiously empty streets and ponder the case. A few blocks away, you hit upon the idea of investigating yourself and your party. You don't know where the rest of the party is at the moment, though. May as well start with yourself.
"Where were you on the day of the crime?"
"Relaxing in my room. You can't prove anything."
"And this room?"
"Carl's Coop."
You hear a scuffle and some shouting a ways off.
"You're not from around here, are you?"
"No, I'd just arrived from a monastery out in the countryside."
You hear some deranged shouting somewhere.
"Were you with anyone?"
"I was with my band of adventurers."
"And does your band have a habit of wearing scarves?"
"What kind of question is that? It's summer and we were hired to hunt down a gang with a habit of wearing scarves!"
"Now, now, B-KAWK, I'm not making any accusations here. I just want to get the story straight. Have you known the victim prior to these events?"
"No. Are we done here?"
"I think so. Thank you for your coöperation in our investigation."
You consider the facts as you walk back to your lodging in this miserable rain. What will you do when you arrive? Perhaps you'd like to go somewhere else before then? If not, what will you start with tomorrow?