Night 1: Zombie Urist is strangled, and neither 4mask or me ended in that room. You were in there, with just above half the people. Persus got stabbed, and was in the other room, with just about less then half of us. Did you stab him too? Note here that almost no-one full-claimed their night 1 actions, and other then someone's word, there's no way to tell when people moved into the new room.
Nexus:
Roo
Fillipk
TheBiggerFish
Dustan Hache
BlackHeartKabal
Statue Hall
4maskwolf
Griffinpup
Persus13 (Bleeding Out)
Teneb
TDS
Tiruin
Tomasque
Night 2: Persus and Teneb died, and the whole retcon thing happened... And Persus became alive. Tiruin got stab-stabbed, and in the end there were 5 people in the statue hall, while the new embalming room was explored. Note here that even people who ended up in the embalming room can't be confirmed town for a couple reasons
1) There's only 1 strangler, but 3? Mafia. Maybe more now if it's a cult, but a night kill makes that unlikely.
2) People in the statue room still had enough actions to move-kill-move-move. In fact, at this stage this action is likely. The nexus was pretty much completely searched round 1, so the only real option for those in the Nexus was to move. This gave potential cover to the mafia.
3) If the strangler searches after kills, then 3 moves in a turn is impossible. But, strangler has other buddies to help him out, which could easily be the people searching. We don't know how often/if anyone's been passing messages, so it's hard to tell how organized the mafia team is. Assuming that it is the killer looting bodies every single time, then it makes sense that those in the embalming room weren't guilty. However, we have a stabber, who isn't under the constraint of looting(which might very well of been Dustan all along). Since they don't kill their target, they don't need 2 actions to attack a target, just 1.
Embalming Room:
Tomasque
Dustan Hache
Deus Asmoth
Nexus:
Fillipk
Statue Hall:
4maskwolf
Griffinpup
TheDarkStar
BlackHeartKabal
Tiruin (Bleeding Out)
Persus
TheBiggerFish
Night 3:
TBF got stabbed(maybe) and it didn't take, whatever that means. And TDS got strangled in the Nexus.
Note here that again, everyone in the Nexus had enough actions to strangle anyone and get back. Everyone in the embalming room had enough actions to strangle someone in the nexus and go back, and everyone moving to the embalming room had an extra action along the way... Which means... Everyone's suspect!!!
Statue Room:
TheBiggerFish
BlackHeartKabal
Embalming Room:
Deus Asmoth
Dustan
Persus
Tiruin
Nexus:
Fillipk
4mask
Griffinpup
Tomasque
Night 4:
Everyone in the Nexus got blown the crap up... Thanks TBF... No one got strangled though, which is interesting when you look at who moved this round. Not going to focus on that right now, but I'd encourage players to look at that.
Statue Room:
TBF
Tomasque
Dustan
Embalming Room:
Fillipk
Persus
Tiruin
Nexus:
4mask (bruised) (bleeding out)
Griffinpup (bruised)
BHK (bruised)
Night 5:
4Mask bled out. No one got strangled?
Nexus:
Griffinpup (bruised) (bleeding out)
TheBiggerFish (bruised)
Dustan
Tomasque
Snake Den:
Tiruin
Persus
Fallacy
BHK (bruised)
So anyways, now response to Dustan.
First, on the point that 1 was at 2 killings.
So was Fillipk.
So was TBF.
You're right that 4mask was too.
So was BHK.
Long story short, that's not indicative of anything. It's really easy for scum to move then attack, or attack and then move, or move attack move... That's not that hard. Moreover, the fact that someone's been to 2 killings doesn't lower the field enough to limit it to scum. Third, you're making an inherent contradiction. You're assuming that one of the people who end in a room where someone is killed are likely to be scum, but no one completely fulfills that description.
Second, on the point that I'm lurking and are therefore scum. LurkTracker doesn't seem to be working... Sadness. However, I'd argue that I'm posting about middle of the road, maybe even more then average. However, the burdon of proof that I'm not posting very much is on you. So Dustan, how much less am I posting then everyone else in this game??
Also, Dustan, next time you have suspicions, raise them before you take a night action. Now, not only did you waste an action stabbing me, you'll make me and another player with a medkit waste their actions. It's just inefficient, especially since we presumably still have people with guns that can enforce any lynch decisions we come to.
So... It looks like FoU is gonna heal me, yes?
I also support the idea of exploring in 2 groups. If we can separate far enough away from eachother that someone can't kill another in the other group without getting back, that'd be optimal.