My Reads:
*
Deus Asmoth: Strong town. All in-thread behaviour is consistent with Wellspring, particularly writing post 116. Unlikely for anything else to purify, and the hostiles were clearly separately active when Deus's post got purified N1.
*
BHK: Strong town. His decision to follow others in voting is consistent with Big Top Mafia town meta, which was itself consistent with old EpicMafia meta. He may stick out like a sore thumb by trying not to stick out, but that's in character for him. Also,
he forgot scumchat. In addition, the scum's trying to kill him. Finally, his claim's accurate to the role he claimed.
*
fillipk: Most likely not part of the scumteam. Mild town. He was voting flabort from the start of D2, never leaving even as flabort was on the verge of being lynched. It would be a damned strange time to bus that hard in any setup, let alone in one where the scum's NK-equivalent is clearly spread throughout the scumteam. His play fits his meta, but is still sort of shallow. Started the O. Wilde third party theory, but wanted to see what Wilde did next before voting (and, in the end, did not vote). His search for scum D2 seems legitimate, though, and got him the right target.
*
Persus13: Most likely not part of the scumteam. Bit of a third party read, though. Competent, thoughtful, attentive, bland. Made a well-thought-out case against BHK D2, then abruptly flipped to flabort for inactivity about 26 hours from the end of the day. This did ensure flabort was lynched, though. I find it hard to see that as bussing in this setup at that time.
*
OSG: Off-neutral read. Claimed Iron Will D2, a good fakeclaim role, but started the claiming process unprompted and unnecessarily. There's been an intense nothingness at the heart of his play, but he's been knee deep in exams for almost all of it. Endless heaps of posts (the most in the game), but little content and depth even in aggregate. Was not voting at the end of D1, and did not vote at all D2.
*
TDS: Mild scum read. Even more of a non-entity, drifting in the background and contributing almost nothing to the game. Has shown a lack of care in his daygame, too, with highlights including
an unvote for reasons irrelevant to
the vote and
a FoS for Persus not voting for the player Persus
was voting for. Main real contribution:
a reasonable vote for Persus when Persus leapt to flabort. Entirely avoided the end of D1 and was not voting then, but was busy.
TDS for now. Let's see his answers/reads/claim/etc...
Persus13: Why did you move your vote from BHK to flabort yesterday?
OSG: Just how much more corruption than normal can you tank? Also, why did you not vote D2?
Unvote now that O. Wilde has explained the counting.
TDS: What did this unvote have to do with O. Wilde's counting? It was the removal of an RVS vote on BHK, and you weren't exactly a contributor to the countdown discussion. Also, based on the material available at the time, who would you have lynched D1 and why?
Author
Topic: Corruption Mafia - Game over! Outsider TheDarkStar wins! (Read 49359 times)