For my part, when I couldn't speak (and was looking for good handles to vote/unvote as a communiction device, but found nonemto my liking) and Moonlight was asking me to talk ("Starver, Id like to speak with you about last night."), it sounded like scum was trying to paint (NPI!) me as guilty-looking. Then he highlights my predicament ("But I think something might be happening to Starver as he's not here...") and redeems a bit of reputation....
But, Moonlit, you then say things the next day that I thought no sane Town would say. But, then again, nor Scum trying to lay low. And I was still thinking that the Garbler (my term) was the person who also knew this, especially as I was still wondering if I was Garbled because I tried to interview Moonlut, so in the absence of any other evidence I took "You see, he thinks I know about the kill and silence because im the one doing it." as some sort of off-the-wall bluff. (Not that it mattered, by then... It was a purely intellectual exercise on my behalf, being dead and all...)
I'd love to say I picked up something from Hector, but it was swamped by Moonlit's strange involvement. I didn't seriously consider Fish, though (read too true, and rightfully confused) so maybe if I hadn't happened to (sorta) interview Moonlit night zero, I might have been on the money. But still dead, so, meh... (I didn't know I was going to die, so I actually asked to interview Fallacy for night 1, before my obituary actually appeared and put paid to that. Don't know if any warning would have helped, given I'd have probably pointed at Moonlit as my swan-song.)