Okkk.....
I would agree with some of those points. And, in retrospect, my play was pretty terrible. Also, I think I might have apologised for calling Frostmoon "he", then still done it. A lot. I
wish I could edit those posts. Sorry. Bad,
bad NJW200. Escpecially if it was the thing that led to Frostmoon sitting out for a bit
In order: "seem": yes, I used vague language as I was saying something hypothetical as I didn't understand Moonlit's post.
I have also looked a bit at tntey, but yeah, couldn't read much on other players...
You know that Moonlit is town
You would know if the first poster was mafia
You think the first post makes someone look town
You almost seem to think that this is a good thing in the long run
This makes me slightly,
slightly suspiscious of you. BECAUSE NOBODY, FIRST POST OR LURKER< IS GOING TO SAY THEY ARE MAFIA. I ASSUMED MOONLIT WOULD CLAIM TO BE TOWN WHATEVER I SAID TO HER, BECAUSE... LOGIC. There's no way she wouldn't, I took it as spoken. Also, my first mafia post. Ever. This is really not hard, and a major error on your part, but hey, maybe you got a bit carried away due to my admittedly scummy play. 2nd point: see first. 3rd point: yeah, I thought conversationality was important. I only read like one game of this. Why is this a problem? I don't really think this is true on all levels, maybe just a superficial one, I was trying to guess at motives. 4. DO you mean the "just a question" thing? I don't entirely understand, clarify.
I probably can't show you a time, except for fairly general questions about Tntey and... you, perhaps once? But I can't get a read on anyone, and to my mind,
Frostmoon is scum. From my read on him, this is a definite enough point to be a cornerstone in my logic. I'm pretty sure this was my only major attack on Moonlit, though, the rest was just trying to understand his play.
Can I just clarify: my suspiscions of Moonlit come from a convition that Frost is Mafia. Try reading the game assuming that she is, the you'll see Moonlit playing a bit more scummily. If however we found out she was not, I would be much more confused and less suspiscious of Moonlit.
Also, nice work not answering my questions. Despite quoting them.
Hope this
answers everything.
And can I apologise wholeheartedly for calling Frostmoon "he", and will try to never do this again.