Everybody,
of the three third-party roles, which sounds the most fun to you?
Probably the Bad, like everyone else. Randomly killing folk without hurting your own winning prospects sounds fun!
Everyone: If you were the Bad, would it be wiser to try to hunt down the Good/Ugly, or just try to live to the end and win with the town/scum? Why?
It would be wiser to just try to live until the end, because it's easier. Wouldn't be very fun though.
This role is probably anti-lurker, because the Good and the Ugly have no real reason (beyond 48 hour voting) to take part in the game.
hector13: As the Ugly, who would you want as the Good? Why?
Someone who wouldn't draw attention to themselves, really.
Not sure I would necessarily choose anyone from this game because I've not played with them much and thus don't know much of their playstyles, but I'd want someone who doesn't draw attention to themselves as they're unlikely to get lynched. If the Confederates are trying to keep the game in a low-information state, it might work against me, but they would still have a 1 in 10 shot of hitting that one player.
I wouldn't choose Shamrock or 4mask though, the games I played with them they were... prominent.
Everyone: Which of the two possible town power roles seems the most useful to you?
In terms of use, Guardsman is best I think. Captain is next, even if there are 2 false-positives in getting Confederate roles, but knowing that any particular player is Union is incredibly useful so you know who
not to vote for.
The General and Angry Private are more... niche I s'pose is how I'd describe it. The General would last one day after revealing themselves, so would only really be useful toward the end of the game, and suffers from the same problem as the Angry Private; namely, it falls on the player to correctly guess who is Confederate in order for them to be useful to town.
Everyone:1. Would any of the third parties merit a policy-lynch if you found out who they were?
2.Should the scum be lynched before a scum-sided Bad or should it be the other way around?
3.If you were town, would you try to help the Good/Ugly, the Bad, or neither?
1. No, not part of the win-con
2. Yes, they are part of the win-con
3. See 1.
I don't like these questions
TDS, you seem to be encouraging town not to vote for the scum. Why is that?