Deus Asmoth:
You're just trying to flip my point here without doing anything to refute it. If a player should be equally careful regardless of alignment, how does making a mistake=scum?
Technically, I think flipping your point just negated the issue, since (as I said) you should be careful about voting whether as town or scum. And making a mistake is not necessarily scummy, but it is something that caught my eye and made me wonder why you could have made the mistake.
I like how you're contiuing to ignore my point. You say I'm scummy for not scumhunting enough. I've pointed out that there are at least two other players in the same situation that you've ignored with little to no reason. Why are you giving Tiruin a free pass instead of asking her more questions to get a better feel for her play if you find it difficult to read her?
I suppose I am just a terrible mafia player for not being able to keep track of all players simultaneously. However, I still don't like you saying, essentially, "You can't call me out for not scumhunting because these two players are scumhunting even less than me!" You're trying to shift my attention off of you and on to Persus13/Tiruin, which is something that doesn't sit right with me.
And as far as Tiruin goes, I've played a number of games with her already, so asking questions specifically to get a feel for her play isn't going to magically happen now if it hasn't already. That said, I still try to keep an eye out for anything I can call her on anyway.
How certain am I that the person I'm voting for is scum? How many people are still alive? How many people are voting for that person? What was the implication that I'm not town in that question supposed to do?
-Not 100%
-9
-3
-Bait you.
Persus13Cheeetar:
Screw it, OSG. Peradon was actually doing exactly what you are supposed to do if you are a town player about to be lynched, which was give reads and claim as much as possible. I don't want to restart the whole giving up argument early D2, but I do think this is scummy enough to make me want to lynch you after reading through this again.
As I mentioned to 4maskwolf, I would just like to point out that we technically tell players in beginner's mafias that what Peradon was doing are scumtells. Damn it. Okay, Cheeetar, what do you make of your predecessor's argument?
4maskwolf:
Shakerag posts from time to time but seems to post for a single two-hour-or-so timeslot on weekdays only, leading to limited interaction.
Still have a full-time job.