Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[LARD]

I'm not sure about this, Darkpaladin. It seems like you're lurking, and kind of complacent. Is it because no one is suspecting you?

[Graknorke]

Sorry about not being posting much. Family visits take up a lot of time.

extend, I could do with another 48 hours.

And LARD, the reason that accepting being lynched for no reason is a scumtell is exactly because it's trying to convince people they're town. But an actual townie would want to prevent a town-lynch (themselves) if possible.

[TheDarkStar]

I'm not sure about this, Darkpaladin. It seems like you're lurking, and kind of complacent. Is it because no one is suspecting you?

If I die and 4mask turns out to be town, someone should check DP. He's the other guy who has been behaving oddly.

Sorry about not being posting much. Family visits take up a lot of time.

extend, I could do with another 48 hours.

And LARD, the reason that accepting being lynched for no reason is a scumtell is exactly because it's trying to convince people they're town. But an actual townie would want to prevent a town-lynch (themselves) if possible.

Not wanting to be lynched versus not caring about being lynched is probably not all that good a scumtell, though, since it's easy to bring WIFOM into it and make conclusions difficult to get (I've seen both sides used as scumtells, actually).

[Graknorke]

But a townie should always want to not be lynched (unless it's to catch the scum, if there's ever a situation where it would help) because each townie lynched is one step closer to a loss.

[4maskwolf]

^This one worries me. It's like he's not trying to stop himself getting lynched.  It makes me think we've picked the wrong guy.


And 4maskwolf. I was looking back through the forum and saw this.

I'd like some elaboration on my questions, please, particularly #1 and #3.  And good on you btw, you've come down to earth after your first posts.  Something I just figured out, as this is my first game here as well, is that people like elaboration and detail, short or vague answers are often seen as scummy. Anyway, you're doing better than me at the beginning of the game, I managed to get 3 ppl jumping on my head.

yeah, about that:
Can I have a reiteration of people's problems with LARD.  I didn't actually understand them when they posted them.

Also, LARD, your sig made me laugh.

Originally I was just flattered, but now I see it a bit as buddying.  I would like to know what your thoughts about me were at that time. I also would like a votecount
[/quote]
Hi LARD.
I was frankly rather bemused at the time and too damn lazy to look back and see what the charges against you were.  I hadn't seen anything I qualified as scummy play from you, so I was asking people to state their cases again so I could read them and scumcheck the cases.  By which I mean figure out which players had weak arguments, as scum often do.

The thing about your sig was idle banter unrelated to the game.

[LARD]

I know there is really no good explanation to idle banter, so that's fine.
I also would like an extend

[4maskwolf]

I would request one, but what is there to discuss?  TDS hasn't answered us, and unless someone else does something scummy my vote is staying put.

[LARD]

Ok guys, I have a plan.

Since some of you are adverse to the whole "lynch one, then the other" plan, how about this?

We lynch one, and our power role target the other?
We have to have either a jailer or a cop, maybe both. When we lynch one, then our power role inspect the other, and if it turns out that we were wrong, then our power role will say so?

I realized while typing this that if we are wrong, then the scum would probably just claim to be the power role. Hmm.

This is a fine idea, because we can afford two more town deaths before lylo, that means if we don't get him now, we can lynch the fake claimer as well as the power role. If nobody counterclaims to the roleclaim, we have to go by what they say and hope they don't get nk'd next night.  In that case we have a confirmed townie and we can scan for mafia from there.  I think this is reasonable, but I am not sure.

[Jim Groovester]

Day 2 proceeds...

[1] 4maskwolf: TheDarkStar
[3] TheDarkStar: 4maskwolf, mastahcheese, LARD
[1] darkpaladin109: Persus13

[3/3] Extend: Persus13, Graknorke, LARD

Day 2 has been extended to Friday 12:00 PM MST.

[TheDarkStar]

I would request one, but what is there to discuss?  TDS hasn't answered us, and unless someone else does something scummy my vote is staying put.

I'd like to point out that while you say that I need to answer, I've actually answered your questions from the last several pages. If you dislike my responses, say so, but then point out to me what it is you want me to answer. The only way that I can satisfy what you want me to do is to re-answer all of the things you have asked me. Since I don't know what I'm looking for, I will probably miss whatever it is you want again. Could you maybe clarify a bit more than "Answer me!" and "You answered wrong!"?

Also, what's the "us" about? I've answered the one other question from someone else (unless I missed someone's post). Are you trying to subtly townclaim?

[4maskwolf]

Us being accusations from the three people lynching you. But very well. I will ask you specific questions in a bit.

[4maskwolf]

Tiruin, could we get your IC advise in here?  Just general advice.

[Tiruin]

Tiruin, could we get your IC advise in here?  Just general advice.

I'll be swooping in soon~ :X
Sorry for the lateness, and the unedited post before!

[4maskwolf]

Tiruin, could we get your IC advise in here?  Just general advice.

I'll be swooping in soon~ :X
Sorry for the lateness, and the unedited post before!

Out of curisosity, how soon is soon?

[Tiruin]

Day 2 has been extended to Friday 12:00 PM MST.

Before this time! :3
Yeah schoolwork kills me. I apologize profusely x-x
Must wooork. Then I'll give a blow-by-blow reaction on everyone's post. Then I'll banter with Jim in deadchat. Then I'll PM Imp because I miss her.
Then...
Oh right.

Soon is before day end, but rather before Thursday in the earliest of timezones. Just a general term so I don't flip on myself and break my spinal column or such.