We should talk first, put down 10 manna to talk with the Justicar leader.
Inform him that we can not hand over our followers, and apologise for them having travelled all this way for nothing, it shows admirable dedication. but inform them that their code of 'law' holds no sway here.
also let him know that we'd be overjoyed to take anyone they deem 'unstable' and 'uncontrollable' off their hands in the future. just send them our way
.
offering them a bit of fire nectar to ease their travel weariness and politely asking them to be on their way home.
if they refuse to leave in peace... well, they'll just have to leave in pieces. We can't have these order Jockies trying to shackle the glorious free flame of life.
Edit: I think we should give the surveyor some slack, He took a chance (a perfect example of chaos) just chuckle a bit at him and say you admire his bravery demanding hush money from a god while being in his domain, and that you'll think about it but have more pressing matters to attend to right now.
edit 2: also about Krait (its not really a priority at this time) but about the 'turnips to snakes' thing, we should let him know that we have no problem with the occasional harmless prank. it breaks up the monotony of everyday life after all. but they keyword should be harmless.
we should also inform our followers about the planned feast at some point... really hoping we're not walking into a trap here. but having godly friends is irresistible.
edit 3: after actually reading the suggestions before mine, I support taking them in as prisoners instead of killing/potential army on our doorstep