IO claiming werebear literally 9 minutes before day end post:
Anyway, I'm not a vig, I'm a PGO; more specifically a werebear. Don't worry though, because I like you all and want to protect you; that said, anyone coming around my place at night is likely to become bear chow. I didn't want to claim immediately because I wanted ZU's reactions without the benefit of that information.
WIFOM. This is inconsequential. If you were a werewolf, would you claim a werecreature?
Vig claim(s):
{Removed for space reasons}
You haven't proven how his softclaiming vig has anything to do with him being scum. You're going to have to give me a good reason why this would make him scum.
Toaster has claimed survivor. That's essentially claiming mafia-ally. Goodbye, Toast.
Fuckit. Urist Imiknorris is a survivor type.
Truth.
Also UI hasn't mentioned Toony being obvtown literally anywhere.
Again, this proves nothing. Your reasoning has thus far gone nowhere.
You cannot simply list things without proving reasons for WHY that makes a person scum. If I don't see why that makes him scum, then you're not really trying. If you provide rationale for why your arguments prove he's scum, then please list them.
HOWEVER. You have stumbled onto one particular clue completely by accident. In the opening pages of the game, Mephensteras clearly says this:
Roles: The available town roles will be known.
Therefore,
IronyOwl, having claimed a role other than those listed on the page, cannot be town.
There's more reasoning, but I'm afraid that I'm going to have to let Dariush finish his explanations, just in case he's simply kicking dirt around.