Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Teneb]

Scapheap, besides all the D1 stuff which you have not adressed, you claim that you "knew" (by your oracle gut, perhaps?) that TDS was the scum goon. If you knew, then why did you not vote for him? When others asked you this, you merely deflected. Furthermore, how could you've known in the first place?

Because that what I choose. I wanted to go for who I thought was the godfather over the 'kill me' goon.

Let's, for the sake of an argument, pretend you are town and knew that TDS was the goon. Even if you wanted to focus on determining the godfather, why not alert the rest of the town to such "obvious" scum?

[origamiscienceguy]

Scapheap Your defense hasn't convinced me and you were dodging questions.

[scapheap]

Scapheap Your defense hasn't convinced me and you were dodging questions.

One two three and that hammertime.

Before I reveal my role, I wonder what question am I dodging? I really can't tell.

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

You are the godfather.

I still can't tell which question...

[TheDarkStar]

It is quickly decided that the contestant calling himself Scapheap is bad. His head also explodes.

His role appears: "Scapheap was the Godfather!"

The host, Jim Stone, returns to conclude the game, award fabulous prizes, drag off two very dead and headless corpses and hide them in the dumpster, and offer some closing remarks.

[TheDarkStar]

Anyway, now you can see why I reversed courses on Scapheap and tried to get myself lynched rather than let him be lynched.

[origamiscienceguy]

Hector13, I must congratulate your very excellent play.

[hector13]

Hector13, I must congratulate your very excellent play.

I was following your lead, and basically being lazy for the most part. Just let you know what I was thinking for the most part, and you did the rest.

[origamiscienceguy]

Thanks, everyone played well. I certainly learned from this match and I hope everyone else did too.

[Jack A T]

Scumchat.

[scapheap]

I'm still in the dark about what questions I dodged?

[origamiscienceguy]

We asked you for your reasoning against voting for TDS and your response was:

You are not me. We will do different things for the same reason and the same thing for different reasons.

[hector13]

We were basically looking for a more in-depth reason for a) why you thought DarkStar was obviously scum, yet you didn't vote for him (you partially answered that, saying Deathsword was godfather, but you didn't say why. The how and why is very important in mafia) b) you didn't explain why you thought Origami or myself were town (this to a lesser degree, but it's important to cover why you read someone a particular way in general)

This also works the other way, if you're not sure about someone, ask them what they think of others, and why. Make them expand on things you don't understand or don't feel they've explained fully.

[Teneb]

I guess scap being the godfather expalined TDS just seeming to give up at the end of D1. Found that quite odd.

[hector13]

I guess scap being the godfather expalined TDS just seeming to give up at the end of D1. Found that quite odd.

I noticed that too, but I thought it was more of an AtE... never expected it to be used to actually get lynched, so it was well played.