Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[origamiscienceguy]

OSG: Who do you think is more scum? Me or DS? Do you need store knives in their fridge drawers without risk?(Note: think of better question.)

At this moment, you were the only one not voting for TDS. If you were sure he was scum, why didn't you vote for him I must ask?

[hector13]

Scapheap, You were the only one not voting for TheDarkStar.

now that you know that TheDarkStar was scum, how does that change your theories.

If you turn out to be the godfather, Origami, I will be most upset.

You seemed to think that Deathsword was the other mafia, why the change of heart now?

Deathsword voted for TheDarkStar. This makes him seem alot less scummy, but It doesn't mean he's completely innocent.

Well there was the whole "If no-one comes up with anything new, I'll hammer" thing. Given that you and I were convinced of DarkStar's scumminess, and Scappy hasn't really done much in the way of scumhunting, it did seem a bit... arbitrary.

Kind of like "Yeah, I'll bus my guy if no-one cares about it enough to change my mind."

I still think scappy is the other scum, but this is because he's now saying DarkStar was obvscum, but didn't vote for him... which is suspicious.

I think Origami is town, it's just deciding between scap and Deathsword now.

[origamiscienceguy]

The Dark star was clearly scum, to the point that he would almost surely be the goon so I went for who I believe to be the godfather.
Since nearly all my theories were TDS was scum, the only thing that changes is that hector and you being mafia can't be true so...

If you were sure that TDS was goon, why didn't you vote for him? If I had a definite goon, and a 1/3 chance of finding godfather, I would defiantly go for the goon.

[scapheap]

OSG: Who do you think is more scum? Me or DS? Do you need store knives in their fridge drawers without risk?(Note: think of better question.)

At this moment, you were the only one not voting for TDS. If you were sure he was scum, why didn't you vote for him I must ask?

The Dark star was clearly scum, to the point that he would almost surely be the goon so I went for who I believe to be the godfather.

The Dark star was clearly scum, to the point that he would almost surely be the goon so I went for who I believe to be the godfather.
Since nearly all my theories were TDS was scum, the only thing that changes is that hector and you being mafia can't be true so...

If you were sure that TDS was goon, why didn't you vote for him? If I had a definite goon, and a 1/3 chance of finding godfather, I would defiantly go for the goon.

You are not me. We will do different things for the same reason and the same thing for different reasons.

[hector13]

That doesn't really explain anything, Scappy.

Indeed, it looks like you're trying to hide something. Are you the godfather?

[origamiscienceguy]

I'll run the math again to see our chances:

Spoiler: calculations (click to show/hide)

This day: 1/4 chance we lynch godfather (town wins), 3/4 chance we lynch town.
Next day, if we lynch town, 1/3 chance we lynch godfather (town wins) and 2/3 chance we lynch town (mafia wins)

Possible outcomes:
This day mafia lynch, town wins (1/4 chance)
This day town lynch and next day mafia lynch, Town wins (3/4*1/3=1/4)
This day town lynch and next day town lynch: Mafia wins (3/4*2/3=1/2)

Town win: 1/4+1/4=1/2
Mafia win: 1/2

So, the game has now become exactly even as far as random chance goes. 1/2 chance town wins, and 1/2 chance mafia wins.

[origamiscienceguy]

You are not me. We will do different things for the same reason and the same thing for different reasons.

Scapheap,please explain your reason then, enlighten me.

[hector13]

Scapheap, seeing as I'm more inclined to believe their scum than Deathsword, for the moment. Also no need to worry about mafia quickhammers.

[origamiscienceguy]

That is true for you, but still, be careful about your vote.

[origamiscienceguy]

My reads at the start of day 2:
Scummyest
Scapheap: You were the only one who didn't vote for TheDarkStar even though you said it was obvious he was scum. Your reason was that you were trying to take a guess on who the godfather was.
Deathsword: You voted for TheDarkStar, but I still have some suspicions about possibly bussing when you saw that TDS was gonna be lynched no matter what.
Hector13: Still think you are town, but you suddenly became a bit reckless with your vote.
Towniest

[Teneb]

Scapheap, besides all the D1 stuff which you have not adressed, you claim that you "knew" (by your oracle gut, perhaps?) that TDS was the scum goon. If you knew, then why did you not vote for him? When others asked you this, you merely deflected. Furthermore, how could you've known in the first place?

[hector13]

It's not really reckless since we still require 3 votes to hammer, which only happens with two townies this time.

I'm quite comfortable thinking that we've got the game solved, if scapheap isn't mafia, then it's likely Deathsword.

[origamiscienceguy]

I'll let Scapheap have a chance at answering everything before I decide whether to hammer him.

Scapheap, what do you have to say in your defense?

[scapheap]

That doesn't really explain anything, Scappy.

Indeed, it looks like you're trying to hide something. Are you the godfather?

We do different things. Let me use a context.

Let say you like horror games, but don't like rpg. And let say I don't like horror games but like RPGs. Why do we play games? Because we both like to do fun things, but here we are playing different games. But there you are going "He doesn't play horror games, so he can't be having fun playing those RPGs because I don't have fun playing those games."

Scapheap, besides all the D1 stuff which you have not adressed, you claim that you "knew" (by your oracle gut, perhaps?) that TDS was the scum goon. If you knew, then why did you not vote for him? When others asked you this, you merely deflected. Furthermore, how could you've known in the first place?

Because that what I choose. I wanted to go for who I thought was the godfather over the 'kill me' goon.

But no, my actions must be the actions of the mafia instead of the townie who gambles.

[hector13]

That's just an expansion of what you said before: "we do the same things for different reasons"

You haven't explained specifically what you thought it was that made you think that DarkStar was clearly scum, nor have you explained why you feel Deathsword was the godfather and Origami and I are town.

I expect some supporting evidence of this, basically the posts that players have made in the game that you think are town-motivated and scum-motivated.