Shark stuff
Sure, whatever, fair enough. I should have stated the reasons for my vote more clearly at the time of voting.
Orangebottle stuff
And now it's not fair enough.
You're asked your opinion of him, and you don't give any clear indication of your view of his alignment.
. . .
You say he's town, claiming your citing the attacks of others indicate this.
. . .
Now, however, the attacks by others don't matter.
. . .
Now, several posts later, you come out with a definitive reason you think he is town. There isn't any real reason to not post this the first time you were questioned for more detail on your read of him.
I'll point out that there's absolutely no reversal or contradiction in my opinion at all through all of your questioning.
I start with: Orangebottle has a shitty day game and that people are taking advantage of him. What I meant by shitty day game is exactly what I eventually explained. I didn't explain this in excessive detail at the start because I didn't think it was necessary.
You say that there was no reason for me not to post what I eventually ended up with, but there was also no reason for me to expect that a more explicitly detailed answer than the one I gave was somehow desired, requested, or required. I thought my answers were sufficient through the whole process. Clearly you don't agree.
Again, this is out of your meta. For someone who is blunt, you're being very slow to explain your reasoning.
The fuck it is.
If I knew what exactly you wanted out of me I would have given it to you right then and there, but because I didn't, this is somehow so completely far and beyond the realm of normal expectations for Jim Groovester that this becomes sufficient grounds to lynch me?
That's ridiculous. Sorry I didn't answer your question quickly enough, bro, because, damn, it's not like it's perfectly legitimately possible that I thought I
was.
Jim:
All day you've been standing back-to-back with me, keeping others from jumping all over me while I try and hunt some scum. My question is, why? I'm justified doing scummy shit as town because my day game is just that fucking awful? This doesn't make any sense. Just because I'm awful as town, it doesn't mean I'm not that awful as scum. I allowed it at the time because it enabled me to hunt easier, but I can't help but question your motives.
You don't have to be a self-loathing mafia player and it doesn't help you at all and if you're aware enough of the problems with your game then you should stop doing the stuff that causes these problems.
Anyway, your points are flawed. If you have just as awful a day game as town as you do when scum, then if you do stupid shit it doesn't really mean anything one way or the other about your alignment. In which case, since it's inconclusive, why would I lynch you over that?
Regardless of your objections to me not thinking you're scum, I've stated repeatedly what my position on you was and why I thought you were town (up until recently). If you want an answer about it you can look through my posts.