Wow, this game is back from the dead. Who could have thought.
Tiruin.
What reason do I have to actually believe anything you're saying here? For all I know you've concocted the cop thing in order to lay blame at my feet, because frankly, this:
N3: I got roleblocked. I could not investigate Pnx.
This strikes me as awfully convenient...
I find it hard to believe a Townie would make something like this up, so honestly, to me, you're looking very, very, scummy right now.
There are two things painfully wrong with this argument. 1) Tiruin can either be a cop or scum right now. Townie is just impossible. 2) Him being 'conveniently' roleblocked actually doesn't change anything - he already found two townies so by process of elimination you and Andrew must be scum. That response really looks like an overreaction, Pnx.
A) I was taking the possibility of "insane townie" into account, and I didn't think immediately accusing him of being scum was productive. Although I suppose if this is how people react to me trying not to be too aggressive...
...
Also when it's 2 in the morning I kind of fail at logic... I didn't actually realize that just left me and Andrew.
B) Him being roleblocked is incredibly convenient, and extremely unlikely.
First we need a cop, 50% chance.
Then we need a roleblocker 50% chance of that to, giving us 25% overall.
Then he needs to guess two times and come up wrong, not that unlikely on their own. I... can't actually be arsed to go calculate the exact odds (if we assume it's random, since it'd have to be more or less just guesswork anyway). But not only did he pick two people who were townies, but he also chose two of the people who weren't killed. Then he got chosen by the roleblocker, also somewhat unlikely.
Then we have to ask the question, "what is the probability that both the cop, and the roleblocker survived this long?"
I'm really too lazy to do the exact math, but I'd guess the total probability of this happening to be around 15%.
My guess is that the roleblocked part is lend credence to the story. It comes across as more sly if he was roleblocked before he ever found scum.
So I guess it's come down to
Tiruin, or me. The question is, do you believe someone who has logic and probability on his side, or someone who is telling a tall tale?