Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

impossible mandates (slade - bug #782, blue jay tooth etc - bug #1623) due to strange preferences (wagon wood - bug #3676 etc)

19 (3.1%)

bug #3169 - Bone carvers suffer art defacement when somebody leaves the map with stuck-in masterpiece bolts

2 (0.3%)

bug #524 - Liquid glob material breath attacks come out solid

2 (0.3%)

bug #1346 - Adamantine thread used for suturing.

13 (2.1%)

bug #2352 - Seasonal ice melting hangs game for a ridiculously long time

8 (1.3%)

bug #296 - Pools/smears/spatters of blood, dust and other materials multiply themselves, get tracked around too much

25 (4.1%)

bug #425 - Dwarves Not Cleaning Blood

14 (2.3%)

bug #2481 - Dwarves will claim new clothes when theirs is worn (xClothesx) but not wear it

95 (15.7%)

bug #3453 - Baron/etc. cannot appoint baron-appointed nobles, such as the Dungeon Master

66 (10.9%)

bug #4025 - Every kobold starves to death at exactly year 4 in world gen

41 (6.8%)

bug #3708 - Ghost names that can't be engraved on a slab and nameless slab engravings

18 (3%)

bug #1498 - Crystal glass items can't be made, CRYSTAL_GLASSABLE appears broken

9 (1.5%)

bug #1582 - Injured dwarf in bed in stocked hospital ignored by idle doctors

30 (4.9%)

bug #231 - Body parts from large creatures (bones, meat, leather, tusks, etc) slow workshops down due to clutter

14 (2.3%)

bug #197 - No wagons in trader/merchant caravans

8 (1.3%)

bug #3942 - Dwarves owning broken clothing. Clothes don't rot, ANNIHILATES FPS.

67 (11%)

bug #3685 - Goblin squads invading a fortress will kill their non-goblin squadmates, sparking loyalty cascade

3 (0.5%)

bug #1376 - Presence of saltwater marsh causes mountain brooks/pools to become salty

5 (0.8%)

Lye, water and buckets  (bug #1324 - buckets full of water were used to produce lye, bug #4230 - bucket with water inside becomes unusable, bug #1236 - buckets contain lye and water, can't be used for anything)

25 (4.1%)

bug #535 - Equipping weapons/armor on military is erratic

46 (7.6%)

bug #3898 - Entire Bone Statcks are used in Reactions instead of a single Bone

14 (2.3%)

bug #2712 - weapons, especially whips, cut through steel armor like butter

27 (4.4%)

bug #4133 - Good/evil plants/trees don't appear (feather trees, glumprongs, sliver barbs, and sun berries)

11 (1.8%)

bug #2327 - Blunt weapons extremely ineffective, extended single combat with groundhog

14 (2.3%)

bug #4550 - Dodging into river/lava/from cliff etc

13 (2.1%)

bug #4552 - Siegers waiting by bodies of dead leaders

10 (1.6%)

bug #4833: When embarking, crashes when memory use reaches 2GB.

6 (1%)

bug #4856: Immortal Dwarf (... Yet unconcious) [or any other creature]

0 (0%)

bug #1609: Immigrant dwarves' skills often don't match their job settings

2 (0.3%)

Total Members Voted: 604

[thvaz]

bug #3942 is not marked as fixed in the bug tracker yet, but I think if he keeps working on clothing bug #535 might be the next to be fixed.

[Kogut]

bug #3942 is not marked as fixed in the bug tracker yet, but I think if he keeps working on clothing bug #535 might be the next to be fixed.

Yeah, I added note "(not marked as fixed, but probably fixed or hidden as result of fixing #2481)". In the worst case producing new clothes will be a workaround.

[Sphalerite]

While it isn't a bug as such, and isn't on the tracker, it really bothers me that all creatures give the same amount of leather when butcher.  A dog and a whale both yield a single piece of leather after butchery and tanning.  I have a hack in place on my custom mods that fixes this, but it's a crude hack and would be better fixed in DF somehow.

[Kogut]

While it isn't a bug as such, and isn't on the tracker, it really bothers me that all creatures give the same amount of leather when butcher.  A dog and a whale both yield a single piece of leather after butchery and tanning.  I have a hack in place on my custom mods that fixes this, but it's a crude hack and would be better fixed in DF somehow.

This one should probably go to eternal suggestion voting (AFAIK almost completely ignored), as it is not a bug.

[HiEv]

While it isn't a bug as such, and isn't on the tracker, it really bothers me that all creatures give the same amount of leather when butcher.  A dog and a whale both yield a single piece of leather after butchery and tanning.  I have a hack in place on my custom mods that fixes this, but it's a crude hack and would be better fixed in DF somehow.

Bug #3732: Butchering a corpse yields only 1 skin, regardless of size

Similarly:
Bug #808: Processing Raw Turtles only makes one shell per stack, and other stack size issues
Bug #4593: shearing sometimes produces stack of 1 wool, which cannot be used
Bug #4616: Spinning stacks of wool only produces a single yarn thread
(and several other items also listed as children of bug #808)

Basically a total mismatch between the amount of material coming in and what is made from that material.

[Kogut]

Bug #3732: Butchering a corpse yields only 1 skin, regardless of size

Added to the list.

[Buttery_Mess]

The trouble is, when you think about it logically, the input/output ratio for materials is pretty messed up all over the show. I mean it takes the same amount of logs to make a table as it takes to make a wooden ring, doesn't it? Seems like a fairly major overhaul of the item reactions would be needed all over to get it working the way it seems it should.

It would be nice for example if Toady modified the charcoal production/use balance, especially with regards to pottery. I mean, you can't make any more constructions with an earthenware brick as you can with a piece of wood, for example; the pottery industry is cool, but totally pointless. This can be fixed with mods easily enough but it feels like something that should be looked at in vanilla.

We don't really have a thread for game balance issues that aren't bugs, though. When you think about it, they're about as important to playability as bugs but entirely subjective.

Don't brooks get saltified by flowing through rock salt bedrock? I've seen forts with saltwater brooks in mountains of rock salt before, I'm sure.

[NW_Kohaku]

The trouble is, when you think about it logically, the input/output ratio for materials is pretty messed up all over the show. I mean it takes the same amount of logs to make a table as it takes to make a wooden ring, doesn't it? Seems like a fairly major overhaul of the item reactions would be needed all over to get it working the way it seems it should.

It would be nice for example if Toady modified the charcoal production/use balance, especially with regards to pottery. I mean, you can't make any more constructions with an earthenware brick as you can with a piece of wood, for example; the pottery industry is cool, but totally pointless. This can be fixed with mods easily enough but it feels like something that should be looked at in vanilla.

Problem with charcoal use balance is that magma forges magma-dump that balance.  Fire clay + magma kiln = free infinite water-tight materials for things like pots without needing wood at all. 

As for feature requests, that's what Suggestions are for, but yeah, it's much, much harder to get Toady to get a feature in than a bugfix.  Still, if you want to talk about the problems with a single log making a whole table or just a single earring - Volume and Mass would be the right place to talk about that.

[drivec]

how about that stagnant water bug

[bombzero]

how about that stagnant water bug

yes... this one is getting quite old, i havn't had a fresh water river in quite some time.

[Immacolata]

how about that stagnant water bug

yes... this one is getting quite old, i havn't had a fresh water river in quite some time.

Stagnant water bug getting quite old, eh? Trying to be funny I see!

I hope small carcass butchering gets sorted out like #874. Some wild animals can't be butchered when shot by a hunter, and you'd kind of wish your hunter would only hunt butcherable animals. But their tame equivalents can. However, its completely opaque to the player what mechanism is there, and you end up thinking the butcher's shop is bugged.

[Kogut]

how about that stagnant water bug

yes... this one is getting quite old, i havn't had a fresh water river in quite some time.

Stagnant water bug getting quite old, eh? Trying to be funny I see!

I hope small carcass butchering gets sorted out like #874. Some wild animals can't be butchered when shot by a hunter, and you'd kind of wish your hunter would only hunt butcherable animals. But their tame equivalents can. However, its completely opaque to the player what mechanism is there, and you end up thinking the butcher's shop is bugged.

Bug #874: Dwarves refuse to butcher some corpses (buzzards in particular), #33: Bronze colossus, skeletal creatures, fleshballs, and others are impossible to kill and #5232: Streams/brooks/rivers getting turned stagnant by nearby pools/ponds added to the list.

bug #3942 - Dwarves owning broken clothing. Clothes don't rot, ANNIHILATES FPS is now marked as fixed on bugtracker.

[Manveru Taurënér]

I'd vote to have #2780 added, fish stocks never regenerating and going extinct after prolonged play. Really annoying to have all my fisherdwarves turn useless and not being able to rely on fishing for food anymore, which I usually rely quite heavily on :>

[Naryar]

Why is bug #4025 still on there ?

[Kogut]

I'd vote to have #2780 added, fish stocks never regenerating and going extinct after prolonged play. Really annoying to have all my fisherdwarves turn useless and not being able to rely on fishing for food anymore, which I usually rely quite heavily on :>

OK, added to the list.

Why is bug #4025 still on there ?

Where? In archival poll results fixed section of current list?

EDIT: I added also famous "Population Cap not working"