Looking back at your claim, I'm reminded of three things:
1: Your claim provided no new information.
It provided new information.
-I'm the cop
-We may have multiple scum left(this was later proved to be impossible)
Information useful to the town?
No, because the only way my claim gets confirmed is if I die. But that wasn't your point. Your point was that it didn't provide any new information, which is inherently wrong.
1: Remember how I said that anything you could claim would be wine? Yeah. When you claimed cop, you weren't actually telling us that you were the cop. You were telling us that you might be the cop, or that you might be scum hoping for a successful claim. The job of proving your cop-ness would have been left to three things: Getting your story straight (and very preferably grounded in reality), providing useful information (a town or scum result on a person, or a roleblock if you weren't going after someone who died that night), and/or a lack of a counterclaim. The only thing you really have going for you is the lack of a counterclaim, and given that there's no guaranteed cop, that's not enough on its own.
So your case is that my claim isn't totally believable?
That's pretty accurate.
2: Proved to be impossible = not useful, and quite possibly a distraction.
Again, your point was that my claim didn't provide any information at all.
Also, you had no reasons to be believing my claim whatsoever, considering what you said right before it, and right after it.
I agree with the "lynch you harder" bit - any pro-town role you could claim would be Wine.
I'll believe your claim, but it doesn't help us all that much (yet), and I was rather hoping that it would paint a clearer image of your attention on Shark.
(also note that you said that way before you wifom'd yourself)
Why would you willingly believe something you've admitted is wine?
Orangebottle's bullshitting. The maximum amount of scum is obvious if you ever read this post. See how the other half of the map is mentioned? The second thief? There's two scum. This is why we've been saying "two scum", or at least the reason I have been. I'm thinking you made up the roleblocking business to get us off of you, and to make your claim feel more legit.
This proves nothing. You're making a massive assumption here: that a human being can't feasibly miss or forget something just because it was said twice. For the record, I've stated that I have no idea why I thought there wasn't a maximum limit on the amount of scumbags. You're still grasping at straws, because your whole case is "oh well there's no possible way he couldn't know it it was clearly stated in two whole posts."
Also, I'm going to admit that there's no reason for any of you to be believing me after all the shit I tried to pull pre-claim. I'd like to know why those of you who believe me are choosing to believe me.