Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[NUKE9.13]

I'm not saying that your flavour is obviously full of holes; I am saying that on closer inspection (eg flavorcops) it might prove to be full of holes.

Hint: it won't be.

...but we only have your word for it. How do you not understand this?
 

Neither did I. But I'm not going to take that and assume that there are no huge holes in anyone's flavour. Because that would be scummy.

I forgot. How is this scummy again?

Because you are discouraging people from looking for said holes by denying the very possibility of their existence.

Sorry for not answering you, but it just wasn't a very interesting set of questions. The answers should be obvious to anyone.

That is literally the worst excuse I have ever heard. You just admitted to deliberately ignoring my questions because they 'weren't interesting'.

Yes.

No, they weren't applicable, because I had no one to apply them to.

Why not?

...because they weren't applicable to anyone. There was no one who had done something I could pester them about.

Wait. How can you assume that you're poisoning with iocane if it isn't spelled out in your role PM?

The fact that is Iocane is spelt out. Can you not read?

It just says that I ... poison someone's wine with Iocane powder

I am clearly a wine merchant, offering free samples.

I just laughed out at this sentence. You aren't even trying.

...look, buddy, if you really think this is that implausible, take it up with Max. There isn't anything else I can say.

[NativeForeigner]

I'd really like to hear more from Orange, see if Dariush suspects anyone else, and hear from Native and Urist as to why they hasn't voted- especially Native.

I'm working things out. This game is odd. I'm mostly trying to figure out if it's worth anything to lynch NUKE.

Extend

Mod: Please prod XanatosJr. He hasn't posted since he freaked out and voted himself. Did he quit?

[NUKE9.13]

Yes. Xanatos is the [ONE REPLACE NEEDED] in the title.

[NativeForeigner]

Yes. Xanatos is the [ONE REPLACE NEEDED] in the title.

Okay, thank you. I wasn't sure if that was Xanatos or Akigagak.

[Orangebottle]

...but we only have your word for it. How do you not understand this?

Except there's no guarantee of a flavor cop either. You could examine what flavor I've given and look for contradictions. If the flavor I posted is fake, there must be a contradiction somewhere, yes?
 

Because you are discouraging people from looking for said holes by denying the very possibility of their existence.

And why would I do that unless my flavor is fake and full of holes?
That's the logic here, right?

Sorry for not answering you, but it just wasn't a very interesting set of questions. The answers should be obvious to anyone.

That is literally the worst excuse I have ever heard. You just admitted to deliberately ignoring my questions because they 'weren't interesting'.

Yes.

...
Go hang.
Intentionally ignoring someone's questions is scummy enough in the first place, especially with a reason like this.

...because they weren't applicable to anyone. There was no one who had done something I could pester them about.

Interesting.
Why do you assume that people need to do something suspicious before you can start scumhunting them?

[NUKE9.13]

If the flavor I posted is fake, there must be a contradiction somewhere, yes?

D:<
WHAT.
...
NO, SERIOUSLY, WHAT.

This is just... blatant, complete, absolute, 100%, total bullshit.

Why must there be contradictions? Are you so fucking incompetent that you can't make something up which doesn't directly contradict itself?

[Orangebottle]

If the flavor I posted is fake, there must be a contradiction somewhere, yes?

D:<
WHAT.
...
NO, SERIOUSLY, WHAT.

This is just... blatant, complete, absolute, 100%, total bullshit.

Why must there be contradictions? Are you so fucking incompetent that you can't make something up which doesn't directly contradict itself?

No. If there is a contradiction, it means I'm probably lying. I never said you had to restrict yourself to looking at only my flavor for contradictions. In fact, that would be terrible. You should compare it to others' flavor too.

Nice overreaction by the way.
You also ignored 75% of my post.

[NUKE9.13]

That's not what you said. What you said was if you are lying, there would be contradictions.
The implication being that if there are no contradictions, you are telling the truth.

I ignored the other 75% because it doesn't merit a response. If you insist:

And why would I do that unless my flavor is fake and full of holes?
That's the logic here, right?

I've answered this.

...
Go hang.
Intentionally ignoring someone's questions is scummy enough in the first place, especially with a reason like this.

This is a flat statement, my response is irrelevant.

Interesting.
Why do you assume that people need to do something suspicious before you can start scumhunting them?

I've answered this.

Happy?

[Urist_McArathos]

I'd really like to hear more from Orange, see if Dariush suspects anyone else, and hear from Native and Urist as to why they hasn't voted- especially Native.

I'm undecided if my vote should go back on to Orangebottle, or Native instead.  I'm not voting NUKE because I believe his claim; claiming lyncher takes balls, as it's a HUGE risk of being killed by the town.  His flavor doesn't seem to indicate that he's a jester, and I'm not ruling out the possibility that Native needs to die either (so we might be able to lynch his target and not hurt our chances of winning).  Long story short, NUKE needs the town more than the town needs NUKE, so he's going to be pro-town out of necessity now (if he isn't, his claim means we can lynch him without fear of losing a townie).  I like having someone that's confirmed around if they're not hurting the town.  I admit I'm going more by flavor than scummy behavior at this point, but I'm alright with that given this is a flavor-based mafia.

[Orangebottle]

That's not what you said. What you said was if you are lying, there would be contradictions.
The implication being that if there are no contradictions, you are telling the truth.

Yes, and you assumed that I meant my flavor would contradict itself. That isn't quite what I had in mind, hence:

I never said you had to restrict yourself to looking at only my flavor for contradictions. In fact, that would be terrible. You should compare it to others' flavor too.

And why would I do that unless my flavor is fake and full of holes?
That's the logic here, right?

I've answered this.

I'm trying to clarify. Answer it again, or quote your previous answer to it.

Interesting.
Why do you assume that people need to do something suspicious before you can start scumhunting them?

I've answered this.

Have you? I don't remember it at all.

[NativeForeigner]

McArathos: Quick question, what about my flavor makes it seem like you need to lynch me? Or is it something I've done in-game?

[Max White]

You guys want a tie that badly?

[Urist_McArathos]

McArathos: Quick question, what about my flavor makes it seem like you need to lynch me? Or is it something I've done in-game?

It's just hard to trust the guy who's come here from out of town, hunting a "wizard" nobody seems to know anything about, and has a record of leaving villages burned to the ground in his wake.  Add to that the fact that Simple apparently teleported out of town after our first lynch, and it makes me wonder what's really going on.

None of this is enough to make me actually push for your lynch, though.  It's just enough to make me leave you in the "maybe" column.

[NativeForeigner]

McArathos: Quick question, what about my flavor makes it seem like you need to lynch me? Or is it something I've done in-game?

It's just hard to trust the guy who's come here from out of town, hunting a "wizard" nobody seems to know anything about, and has a record of leaving villages burned to the ground in his wake.  Add to that the fact that Simple apparently teleported out of town after our first lynch, and it makes me wonder what's really going on.

None of this is enough to make me actually push for your lynch, though.  It's just enough to make me leave you in the "maybe" column.

Fair enough, just curious.

[Jack A T]

Max White: When is the day supposed to end?  It's somewhat hard to get the right time pressure for people to break ties to make sure someone scummy gets lynched when nobody knows when the day will end.  Please, pick a solid time.