Since you guys are here, opinions are welcome regarding the cheating question and the modkill vs. replace question.
What do you mean by cheating? If I ever mod, blatant cheating will result in a modkill and the refusal to ever let that person in my games again. Simple as that. If it's something less well defined, it has to be on a case by case basis. Depends on how badly it breaks the game.
So far as modkill vs. replace (I'm guessing when they're lurking?), I'd say modkill. It's hard to find replacements and harder for them to catch up in the game and for everyone to adjust their reads accordingly (from nothing to something considering the circumstances). Just kill them and move on with the game and (at least hopefully) people will stop lurking.
That's not to say that people cannot request replacements. If they do, they're still expected to play actively until a replacement shows up or be modkilled.
Mostly though, it'd be up to the mods IMO.
Maybe I'm too harsh... I dunno...
Stop being a nuisance Elegy, ever since you've had that new avatar you've been an asshole.
Oh well fuck me for trying to get you guys to make your own thread.
You don't need Webadict or Eduren to make a thread, you can go do it on your own. It's not that hard, honest, I have total faith you can press the "new topic" button all by yourself!
Why? A new thread for a new attendance board should be started by whoever will maintain the thread so they can edit the OP. This game is over and provoked the conversation due to the extensive lurking, so it seems to me to be a good place for it.
If you want the forum to stop telling you about new posts to this thread, just click the 'Unnotify' button. It's not that hard.