Oh,
hell yes.
Cool story, bro.
Again, cool story. Your suspicions don't actually mean shit, and you still aren't denying that Toaster has been doing a perfectly good job at scum hunting. And guess what! So have Mr. Person, SirBayer, and Lonewolf. In mafia, buddying should be the least cause for concern.
Wait, did you just say this? That's ridiculous. Buddying is a perfectly valid scum tell. Especially when you ask weaksauce questions to the guy you think's doing a great job of scum hunting, or otherwise interact with him in a forced manner.
And don't cool story me. Completely ignoring my suspicions would have been a better move, since it would have shown you were not concerned about them, which is a good thing for a town to be. Going out of your way to brush them aside means you're worried and just putting on an unconcerned face.
Cutting him off by the knees every time he tried to make a (albeit awful) point is still considered 'attacking' in my book. In fact, just throwing constant doubt on him would be a great way to get a foolishly acting town lynched easily.
So acting like a spaz means someone is a scum? I'm not sure I follow. In my experience from mafia games, it's usually an over-eager town who gets themselves flustered and then melts down later who acts like a spaz. It doesn't seem right to cast a vote for someone who you still could consider a town.
That's naive. So incredibly naive. I'm not sure if you actually believe this or you're just trying to look good by grabbing the moral highground for ToonyMan's mislynch. Either way, not a favorable position to be in.
Nothing I did got ToonyMan lynched, aside from the vote. That was
all ToonyMan. Using ToonyMan flipping town to go after people is a rookie mistake at best, and a scum move at worst. So, which are you?
That's not how this works. You answer my question before you ask me the exact same question. I'll answer your first question, however.
Okay, I think Criptfiend was killed because he was suspicious of Mr.Person and someone wanted to capitilize on that. Of course, that would rule out Mr. Person offing him for the same reason, but it's unlikely that a mafia would do something so obvious.
Your turn!
Roughly the same. Criptfeind was not the strongest townie in the game, so nightkilling him was probably a step to use against a more powerful townie that Criptfeind suspected.
Using nightkills as reasons to suspect people rarely works out, since the motivations for the scum team are rarely known for certain.
Furthermore, never discount that the mafia would not go with the obvious course of action. Eliminating direct opposition usually works out very well, since again, nightkills are mostly untraceable.