Heres the list Toaster asked for. From scummiest to towniest:
1. Criptfeind.
2. Ottofar
3. Leafsnail.
4. Azure.
Now, for my actual thoughts. Cript and Otto are the scummiest players here. Otto has posted zero content, used Web's words as justification, been extremely jumpy with his vote, and has given poor or no justification in his votes.
Cript has been very scummy to me. He has been all over the place with his suspicions. There is also how he has responded to others being suspicious. Day 1, he claimed that Nuke was obvious scum. Rather than help put pressure on him, in order to get him to crack if he was scum and confirm it, he did the illogical and went and attacked others. When called out on it, it lead to the shit storm that was Leaf vs. Cript. And during Day 2, he decides not to try to lynch Leaf because he was sure that Leaf was the one that the wolves attacked. I seriously doubt that he would know that, unless he was a werewolf. He stated that it would be stupid for the scum teams to not attack him or Leaf. He says that since they both lived and wolves hit a mafia member, Leaf must be mafia and was hit last night. He uses that as a reason to go after other players and not vote Leaf. Then he continues his inconsistant behavior. I believe he is a werewolf, which is why he believes Leaf is mafia and was attacked last night. His reason a townie would know just seems too farfetched to me.
As for Leaf, he hasn't acted all that scummy to me. However, if Cript turns out to be a werewolf, I doubt he will have lied about the wolves attacking Leaf during the night. We'll know when Day 3 starts up.
As for Azure, he doesn't seem really scummy to me. His predecessor has buddied with Cript a bit, but he personally hasn't done anything really scummy to me. Same goes with just about everyone else.
All in all, Cript has been scummiest to me. So I'm putting my vote on Criptfeind.
(Sorry if this seemed a bit incoherent, I'm kinda tired.)