Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Solifuge]

I could take the time to explain it, but it's really not important now.

Spoiler: The Plan (click to show/hide)

Neither ExKirby nor CobaltKobold and I are siblings; that was a bluff to keep them from nightkilling me, if either were scum. I PMed both of them with that info, hoping to elicit one of three reactions:

1) If one was scum and one was Town, then the Scum one would most likely take the bluff and not kill me.
2) If they were both scum, they would have shared the info about their separate PMs, realized it was a bluff, and most likely killed me.
3) If they were Town, they would think I was a Serial Killer, and react as though I was Scum.

Last night, ExKirby was given a Skulkifier, which will kill him if he is targeted by any night action. Nirur Torir was the Good Samaritan, who gave me an extra vote on Night 1. Thinking him Scum, I wanted him to target ExKirby, such that he would die, and the resulting Role-Flip would indicate whether he was the Scum player in Possibility 1, thus implying that Cobalt was clear.

Kashyyk was included as a control, in the event that Nirur Torir was Scum disguised as a positive role, and sought to sabotage the plan by not giving his Bonus Vote to ExKirby. I notice that he most didn't do this... This was probably the result of him trying to not use the information on the PM though.

But yes.

Nirur Torir gave me his vote yesterday, and that allowed yesterday to be a tie.

Solifuge, your scheme is, frankly, horrible, if I read how you're saying it works correctly. If you think that Exkirby is scum, then you can't actually lynch him now that you're sibs, because you'd die too, 1:1, and the nightkill would give them the equality needed to win.

Voting and exploding both of you would be fine (if one scum/one town), because it'd be like lynching a Hated mafioso- you get a lack of night.

CobaltKobold, did you intend to FoS me there? I find this very interesting. Especially because you just advocated lynching me to kill ExKirby as well. You assumed that my ability would take both of us down, saying that this was "A good idea if one was town, and one was scum".

Its strange also that you just assumed ExKirby is scum based on my suspicions, without even questioning it... it's almost as though you hoped that we were siblings, and that you could seal a victory by killing 2 townies in one lynch.

CobaltKobold I am calling you out.

[Eduren]

It seems that ExKirby is asking to be replaced in this.

Also. Kashyyk. Get out of the shadows. What is up with you?

[Leafsnail]

Kashyyk and ExKirby have both requested replacements.

I myself will be away from monday, but only until thursday, so it shouldn't affect the running of the game.

[Vector]

Notice will be up on the signboard once I've finished starting BMIX up ._.

[Eduren]

*groan*

[Solifuge]

Quick, while he's gone, let's lynch everybody!

No seriously. CobaltKobold and Eduren are probably scum. ExKirby reacted with panicked You Must Be Scum behavior, so I think he's clean anyway.

Also, why is it that all the people I PMed suddenly die or want replacements. Am I that unpleasant?

[Eduren]

Quick, while he's gone, let's lynch everybody!

No seriously. CobaltKobold and Eduren are probably scum. ExKirby reacted with panicked You Must Be Scum behavior, so I think he's clean anyway.

Also, why is it that all the people I PMed suddenly die or want replacements. Am I that unpleasant?

That came out of nowhere. Why?


Unvote. Since replacements are fun.

Meph, you don't seem to concerned about lylo. Who is scum?

[CobaltKobold]

Solifuge, your scheme is, frankly, horrible, if I read how you're saying it works correctly. If you think that Exkirby is scum, then you can't actually lynch him now that you're sibs, because you'd die too, 1:1, and the nightkill would give them the equality needed to win.

Voting and exploding both of you would be fine (if one scum/one town), because it'd be like lynching a Hated mafioso- you get a lack of night.

CobaltKobold, did you intend to FoS me there? I find this very interesting. Especially because you just advocated lynching me to kill ExKirby as well. You assumed that my ability would take both of us down, saying that this was "A good idea if one was town, and one was scum".

Its strange also that you just assumed ExKirby is scum based on my suspicions, without even questioning it... it's almost as though you hoped that we were siblings, and that you could seal a victory by killing 2 townies in one lynch.

CobaltKobold I am calling you out.

You misread me. I said lynching the sibs are a bad idea, because dropping town and mafia both one and shifting to night phase is equivalent to nolynching in (non-3p) lylo, handing the mafia the win. (Similarly bad is the case whereby you're both town.) I'd only want to lynch a mafia-sib if it were 3p lylo, because any earlier lylo wins for mafia. And, if you control your sibbing, then it's unlikely you'll pick your scumbuddy, unless that's part of the ability.

What I said was that, if at least one of you is scum (my hypothesis being on YOU, not Exkirby, hence why the FoS is on you) and the "blows up when voted" thing is on, and you're still sibbed...then, unless I thought both of you were town (I don't) I'd go with it, because it'd be like a correct lylo lynch followed by NK, since it would be dayphase with each side down one.

CONCLUSION: Stop putting words in my mouth, scum.


Finally it's LYLO. You don't vote unless you're damn sure you're voting scum or b. you ARE scum- because if you vote nonscum, the scum can quickhammer FTW Oh, right, deadlines.

[Pandarsenic]

Despite my, ah, economized posting, CobaltKobold, there was never anything like that, unless you mean the Skulkifier, which Solifuge wanted to use in conjunction with the Nonvoting Motivator's power to kill someone. Were you just trying to get us to mislynch?

[CobaltKobold]

Alright. You've shown that you're about 85% trustworthy, and since you already have a night-based power, I'm willing to bank on it. As such I'm going to need to rely on you for a last-ditch gambit.

I'm counting on dying tonight, but I've set up a scenario with my power that should out at least 1 Scum on Day 3. If I'm alive tomorrow, either ExKirby or CobaltKobold are Scum, but not both of them. If I am dead, then either they both are Scum, or they both are Town.

The reason we can deduce this is because both of them received PMs that I attached a machine to them, which will kill them if I die tonight. This is only a partial bluff; a machine was, indeed, attached to ExKirby. It will kill him if he is ever targeted by a night ability.

As such, I need you to give him your vote, which will kill him. We can use his role-flip the next Day, and whether or not I am dead to deduce if CobaltKobold was in cahoots with him or not: If they're both Scum, they'll share information about the PMs, and realize it was a bluff. If only one are Scum, they'll most likely take the bait and kill someone else to preserve themselves. Of the two, I'm pretty sure he is Scum. I don't know about CK though.

Anyway, I can't pull this off without your backup. If you'd like the insurance, I will send a simple message to a suspected neutral party that "The thing that Nirur will say tomorrow is true. Don't show publicly that you trust him, until the Scum try to get him lynched. If he is dead tomorrow morning instead of me, I will explain everything."

Sound good to you?

P.S. My suspects for Scum are anyone that claim to have a Day power, such as Mephansteras' "Overconfident Guy", ExKirby's "Voodoo Medium", and maybe Eduren's "Sticky Voter". Though the power checks out, I suspect that it is a "Horrible Scum Role", much like a "Horrible Town Role".

P.P.S. There is a check in place, just in case you're Scum. It'll muck up the Scum Detection plan, but will at least out your allegiance. It also leaves me dead, so please don't be Scum.

Number of people attacking me with outright falsehoods: 2

[CobaltKobold]

Oh. I misread the meaning of "give him your vote" as "vote for him". My mistake.

[Mephansteras]

Meph, you don't seem to concerned about lylo. Who is scum?

Where do you get that from? I've been a bit busy the last few days so I haven't been as active as I'd like, but I've been doing what I can to make sure we don't lynch anyone based on bad info.

As for who's scum...I'm not positive. I'm guessing not Solifuge, and probably not ExKirby. Everyone else is suspect.

I'm going to try to do a full scan of everyone once I get a chance.

[Solifuge]

I'm betting on Exkirby or Mephansteras being nonvoter scum.

What I said was that, if at least one of you is scum (my hypothesis being on YOU, not Exkirby, hence why the FoS is on you) and the "blows up when voted" thing is on, and you're still sibbed...then, unless I thought both of you were town (I don't) I'd go with it, because it'd be like a correct lylo lynch followed by NK, since it would be dayphase with each side down one.

So you think ExKirby is Scum, then I call you out, and suddenly he's clean and I'm scum, eh?

CobaltKobold has gained a level! CobaltKobold has learned "OMGUS"!

[Solifuge]

I somehow butchered the above quote dates in copy/pasting, but corrected it.

The last 7 digits of the date weren't copied, and we ended up in 1969.

[CobaltKobold]

...That's not even what OMGUS means. :|

The 'scum' part was because I didn't really believe that town would get a nonvoter role, since it would reduce their daygame so much.

You're really grasping at straws to try to frame me here.