Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Crystalizedmire]

So hector said he knows a kill was attempted. Assuming he is telling the truth the only possibility I see would be that he's knight(and his lack of response to my question would mean that it is obvious). This means that snowkiller is scum(neither I nor sofanthiel could be scum because I was guarding sofanthiel's house). However, I doubt that since MS wanted to lynch snowkiller unless MS is third party. So we could probably learn more information by lynching hector even if he's not the most suspicious(TricMagic).

On second thought, if we're lynching you today your info is actually really valuable. OK. I protected someone last night.

So does that mean that you're also guard or is there another role that allows people to protect others?

You think Snowkiller is almost certainly scum but you'd rather lynch Hector and you think TricMagic is more suspicious? What?

Looking back on it now, lynching hector is probably a bad decision. However, my main reason for voting out hector is to see whether or not he is telling the truth about being knight. This would confirm that there was an attack on night 1. Also, I just realized that lynching hector can't actually confirm or deny snowkiller being scum(since it is just as likely that 2 veterans are scum). So let's vote TricMagic since sacrificing 1 probably townie life for the sake of information is probably a bad idea.

You seem a little desperate to back away from Hector here. TricMagic could obviously also be a townie and will provide less information if lynched; how would lynching him be advantageous?

My reason for lynching TricMagic is that they seem more suspicious than hector since I could vaguely recall Tric and MS voting the same player. Another reason is that if hector is actually scum then why would they lie about being attacked? The one possible explanation I could think of is that the protection you made prevented hector from killing anyone.

[ToonyMan]

Why does Tric make more sense than Snowkiller to you Toony?

It doesn't.

I've given it some thought after Elephant talked about Tric and I think Tric is still very town.

I also think you're probably town because otherwise you decided to no-kill which seems crazy to me. Unless you tried to kill Elephant's target. I think Crystal would have died if you tried to kill Sofanthiel and they're being truthful.

So Snowkiller does make the most sense here. In a lame POE way.

[ToonyMan]

Another reason is that if hector is actually scum then why would they lie about being attacked? The one possible explanation I could think of is that the protection you made prevented hector from killing anyone.

Hector probably isn't mafia unless they tried to kill Elephant's target.

Elephant doesn't want to say who they are because they know that player is town.

[Elephant Parade]

Another reason is that if hector is actually scum then why would they lie about being attacked? The one possible explanation I could think of is that the protection you made prevented hector from killing anyone.

Hector probably isn't mafia unless they tried to kill Elephant's target.

Elephant doesn't want to say who they are because they know that player is town.

What do you mean by this?

[Snowkiller]

I just want to know what the person who started the Maximum Spin train thought of their playstyle/wording to earn them a vote in the first place. That was a great D1 read.

[Elephant Parade]

TM, I think I might get your meaning, assuming you were being vague on purpose.

[ToonyMan]

Another reason is that if hector is actually scum then why would they lie about being attacked? The one possible explanation I could think of is that the protection you made prevented hector from killing anyone.

Hector probably isn't mafia unless they tried to kill Elephant's target.

Elephant doesn't want to say who they are because they know that player is town.

What do you mean by this?

No one died, including Crystal, therefore:

1. Mafia no-killed, this means Hector is lying and mafia.
2. Hector is telling the truth and was attacked, this means Hector is town and mafia is probably Snowkiller by POE.
3. Hector is lying and actually tried to kill Elephant's target, this means Elephant's protected town.

So to correct my logic, Elephant knows their target is town if Hector is lying.

I just want to know what the person who started the Maximum Spin train thought of their playstyle/wording to earn them a vote in the first place. That was a great D1 read.

Is this an admission of guilt?

[hector13]

Pretty sure it was Caz.

[Crystalizedmire]

Another reason is that if hector is actually scum then why would they lie about being attacked? The one possible explanation I could think of is that the protection you made prevented hector from killing anyone.

Hector probably isn't mafia unless they tried to kill Elephant's target.

Elephant doesn't want to say who they are because they know that player is town.

I can't believe I phrased it that way. Ye, that was what I meant to see

[Crystalizedmire]

Pretty sure it was Caz.

can you elaborate?

[Snowkiller]

I thought the collective IQ would be higher in this game. How about asking why mafia no-killed? Sure, I'm no veteran of this genre (far from it), but I'm pretty sure mafia always kills at night unless they're blocked from doing so. I really don't get why I'm seeing "ahh, there was no kill last night, therefore, x or y player is mafia." That literally makes zero sense. How about you try to see if a town role is out here blocking people, OR go through the gamut of reasons why mafia would skip? There's an idea, I'd think.

[ToonyMan]

Pretty sure it was Caz.

I also think it was Caz, surprising no one.

[Elephant Parade]

My target was Snowkiller.

[ToonyMan]

Daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaammmmmmmmmmmmmnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn

[Elephant Parade]

Yeah.