Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ToonyMan]

Who do I believe at this point??

[webadict]

Max did in fact tell me what he did last night.

So... It's Magma Mater and ToonyMan?

Also, why am I not being suspected anymore?

Oh, you are being suspected. Just not as much.

Yes, I see that. I am not entirely sure why, but I assume that the ringing in my ears is my fillings picking up radio waves, and not my Tinnitus flaring up.

O overlords, please feed us poor beleaguered fools some morsels.

just claim your target jack so that we can all move on with our lives, thanks.

'Twasn't I. I can hear a voice in my head, and it's not Euchre's.

Also, he just said Roden was suspicious, so either Roden is the world's worst negotiator, or the radio fell into ToonyMan's dictatorial grasp, and I will be executed shortly under the hellish regime that has formed. I only request that a state funeral be held.

Anyway, for real, if Max is cleared, it probably not Euchre and Max, so it really is between us three. Neither Roden nor I can be confirmed, so if you have a confirmable action, you should literally claim it, Magma. It only hurts you to not do so.

[ToonyMan]

If I assume Roden is town and telling the truth:

Roden is town
Max is 75% town
Jack is most likely town
Magma and Web are the mafia


If I assume Magma is town and telling the truth:

Magma is town
Roden and Web is probably town
Max is probably mafia
Jack is mafia

[Magma Mater]

Max did in fact tell me what he did last night.

So... It's Magma Mater and ToonyMan?

Also, why am I not being suspected anymore?

Oh, you are being suspected. Just not as much.

Yes, I see that. I am not entirely sure why, but I assume that the ringing in my ears is my fillings picking up radio waves, and not my Tinnitus flaring up.

O overlords, please feed us poor beleaguered fools some morsels.

just claim your target jack so that we can all move on with our lives, thanks.

'Twasn't I. I can hear a voice in my head, and it's not Euchre's.

Also, he just said Roden was suspicious, so either Roden is the world's worst negotiator, or the radio fell into ToonyMan's dictatorial grasp, and I will be executed shortly under the hellish regime that has formed. I only request that a state funeral be held.

Anyway, for real, if Max is cleared, it probably not Euchre and Max, so it really is between us three. Neither Roden nor I can be confirmed, so if you have a confirmable action, you should literally claim it, Magma. It only hurts you to not do so.

Why would Max be cleared? Who is he cleared by?

[webadict]

Roden clears him, so if you wanna say Roden + Max, that's a choice, I guess, but that still leaves Euchre as Town.

[webadict]

Either that, or Max won a coinflip. It's just not very likely Max is scum unless Roden is scum.

[Magma Mater]

Anyway, I was blocked last night. The red check is the realization that Jack used two actions on night one. Even from the PoV of other people, I don't think there's any possibility other than Jack being the person who blocked Roden night one. This is something we should have realized yesterday, but I was too stubborn in my thinking that there was an error of some sort at play.

[EuchreJack]

Anyway, I was blocked last night. The red check is the realization that Jack used two actions on night one. Even from the PoV of other people, I don't think there's any possibility other than Jack being the person who blocked Roden night one. This is something we should have realized yesterday, but I was too stubborn in my thinking that there was an error of some sort at play.

Would you mind running through your theory for the benefit of those who aren't me, at the very least?
I for one did NOT use two actions ever.  But I'd like to hear your theory, and if you want the votes you'll need to convince others as well.

[EuchreJack]

Magma, it very much sounds like you're making a soft doctor claim.  If we should be thinking anything else, maybe you should tell us something?

[webadict]

Anyway, I was blocked last night. The red check is the realization that Jack used two actions on night one. Even from the PoV of other people, I don't think there's any possibility other than Jack being the person who blocked Roden night one. This is something we should have realized yesterday, but I was too stubborn in my thinking that there was an error of some sort at play.

I see. So then you think it's Max and Euchre or Euchre and Toony (But not Max and Toony)? Because that theory relies on you thinking Roden and I are both Town.

[Maximum Spin]

I see. So then you think it's Max and Euchre or Euchre and Toony (But not Max and Toony)? Because that theory relies on you thinking Roden and I are both Town.

It honestly can't be Euchre and Toony unless you believe one of the following:
1) They chose to nokill for no discernible purpose despite allegedly having multitasking
2) The kill is delayed/evens only/something else (it's possible, in theory, that the action you counted on Jim wasn't actually the kill, for example)
3) Magma really is claiming doctor and protected the true victim, in which case he should fess up already
or 4) they inexplicably decided to both choose me as their neighborizer dupe and try to kill me at the same time, since I was the only person confirmably unkillable that night.

[Maximum Spin]

Soooo, does anyone want to revise my action list in any way? Magma? You sure you don't want to claim?

[Magma Mater]

These are the claims:

Magma Mater: Ninja ??, targeted ?? n1, blocked n2.
Roden: Unreliable Cop, blocked n1, green on Max n2.
webadict: Motion Detector, saw 3 on EuchreJack n1, saw 1 on Jim n2.
ToonyMan: Unreliable Inventor, gave ?? to EuchreJack n1, gave ?? to ?? n2.
Maximum Spin: ??, blocked n1, did ?? n2.
EuchreJack: 2-shot Neighborizer, targeted Maximum Spin n1, targeted ?? n2.

From these claims, I think it's nearly confirmed to everyone that there is a mafia roleblocker. For there to not be a mafia roleblocker, you have to assume that Roden and I are both mafia. To assume that, you have to believe that Roden was given a useless Cop role (we know that he has this role, since there were multiple millers) as mafia. I think you'd have to take a pretty big leap in judgement to believe this.

Ahhh shit I have to go, but posting this so that I have it on my PC later.

[Magma Mater]

Edited to remove all the emoji from above. Jesus Christ.

[EuchreJack]

Yeah, don't edit