Okay, just looked through flabort's posts, didn't notice any questions for OSG. Considering that he claimed to have a null read on him, the only player that's the case for, why are you not pressuring him?
Ah. Sorry, I didn't mean to miss this; it just didn't look like a question directed at me.
Yeah, there's something I've been forgetting to do. I've just been so busy between my Christmas gifts and convincing the players that you are not to be trusted any further than you trust me, that I really haven't had the time to come up with a decent case against OSG or Fallacy.
I do have to say, Fallacy does feel a little suspicious; unless you've been bussing him, though, I doubt his appeals to experience are going to be much of an issue (Re: "That's why I've been town reading you, Hector", "Now THAT'S how you do an attack! I wish I could do an attack like that"). It's more of a novice town thing than the things you've been reading Saber as novice town for.
So... case against OSG... their ability claimed, allows them to see the Clone Lord, and any other alignments that might not have started out as town. Seems legit enough, nobody counter-claiming, and just powerful enough, when combined with Chromatic Wasp, to equal one cop. Except split between two people, to increase it's power over the increased power of a cult. Balance wise, it's perfect; a genius move by Deus Asmoth. Almost too perfect... basically, to determine whether or not OSG should be a suspect, specifically a suspect over my current top suspect Saber or even over FoU, we need to determine whether or not it's a fake claim. Which... is nearly impossible, if it is a fake claim they did a bang-up job of picking who they allegedly targeted.
So.... on to this.
What does everyone else think of OSG's stance?
The fact that it comes down to opinion? Well... yes. At this point, we are all disregarding whatever we don't agree with, whatever is irrelevant to our own opinions. Something new is required to breath any sort of new life into the conversation, or else we're all going to sit here in a stalemate. Which means either Saber needs to come back and comment on everything he can, or we'll need to pick someone to lynch right now and then shorten.
And I promise, I'm not putting it off any more. If we don't lynch Saber, I will kill him tonight.
If we do lynch Saber, then who I go after depends on his flip. If it's town, probably Fallacy. If it's clone-lord, Hector. If it's converted-clone, then I guess I should kill either Hector or Fallacy. If he's a third party... well, that depends on which third party, but I'd probably go after OSG because in all other scenarios I'm killing Hector or Fallacy.
On the other hand, if we lynch OSG and he flips clone lord or clone, I'm killing Hector instead of Saber.
So... we have three more days to decide, should we lynch Saber, OSG, or Fallacy. I'm leaning... Saber, but on the chance that he's cult, I really want to find out what happens if we lynch OSG now. Call it... scientific curiosity. I'm keeping my vote on
Saber for now, though.
OSG Which would you rather, for town's best chance at winning. We lynch you and I go after Saber or Hector depending on your flip, or we lynch Saber and I go after Hector or FoU depending on his flip? Or, third option, we lynch FoU and I kill Saber no matter what. What, in your opinion, would lead to the best outcome for town? Consider all these possibilities as to whether I am fake-claiming my role or telling the truth, and make your choice.
Fallacy Same question. Considering what I have said who I will kill in each case, who do you think I should kill.
Author
Topic: A Game of Clones: Game Over, Town-Cult Draw! (Read 52854 times)