Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Jack A T]

mod fix quote tags pls ty

roo: Not within my power, sorry.

allow the analytical mod here to focus on filipk.

[ANALYSIS REDACTED]

Frostmoon has requested a replacement!

[roo]

(new guy hasn't said anything interesting or useful)

Why didn't you answer my question, Roo? Why shouldn't I vote for you?

If you can't figure it out me leading you there isn't gonna help you. Start posting actual content and we'll go from there as you have yet to post anything with substance.

[NJW2000]

ICs Do replacements ever help town much? Other than replacing a good with a worse player, as that goes both ways obviously?

[Ddynamo]

If you can't figure it out me leading you there isn't gonna help you. Start posting actual content and we'll go from there as you have yet to post anything with substance.

Regardless, I don't think we should lynch Tntey just yet. I was thinking we could wait a little bit, and see if anything's changed by the next lynch. For now, I'm going with the majority. Frostmoon.

[roo]

ICs Do replacements ever help town much? Other than replacing a good with a worse player, as that goes both ways obviously?

Yes they do help to move the game forward. Unless you are talking about: skill, likability, charisma, or style. Then it is completely dependent on who is being replaced and who is replacing in.

[roo]

I'm okay with a filipk/tnt/dynamo lynch.

[Ddynamo]

I'm okay with a filipk/tnt/dynamo lynch.

Have I done something wrong?

[fillipk]

No I think he's trying to get a reaction out of us.

[fillipk]

Sorry, I haven't payed to much attention to this today and I missed the bandwagoning.

[Ddynamo]

If you can't figure it out me leading you there isn't gonna help you. Start posting actual content and we'll go from there as you have yet to post anything with substance.

Regardless, I don't think we should lynch Tntey just yet. I was thinking we could wait a little bit, and see if anything's changed by the next lynch. For now, I'm going with the majority. Frostmoon.

Why are we trying to lynch someone who's requesting a replacement? Just saying, it'd be pretty crappy to say "Hey guys!", followed by, "Oh wait, I just died." with no way to defend themselves as they won't know why we're voting them.

Fair point. Unvote

[fillipk]

~snip~
After seeing Griffion's stuff:

RE: Tntey thing: thinking out loud: we fail to lynch him, mafia rolecop him, he is nightkilled if cop, probably not if not. Now, would he be a liar if he wasn't a role player? And though he's trying to save himself, lynch all liars! So I agree about not lynching TNTey, but if he doesn't get nightkilled, we lynch him tommorrow for lying/being mafia?

  This would, however, mean that mafia could rolecop him, and not nightkill  if he had a role, so we lynch a town role the next day. So this route is not an amazing one to go down, I believe.

Then we have to go by his actions and he's acted too much like scum to let, I'm okay with sparing him day 1 but if he's still alive day 2 we need to lynch him.  Unvote

@Roo stuff  I'm getting a town read off Roo which is why I mostly ignore him instead of voting him.

@NJW2000  One question, Lets say I claimed jailkeep and said I was going to jail you, what would the mafia do?

[fillipk]

*edit*

And what would I the jailkeep do.

[fillipk]

Since day is about to end answer it tomorrow if you don't get it today.

[roo]

extend people said they were preparing posts

[fillipk]

extend It gives time for NJW to answer my question and for me to decide who to vote