Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[4maskwolf]

Bwuh your IC forgot this game was restarting.  Sorry about that.

NQT: Erm... what?  That logic used for voting me is troll logic at best, and makes absolutely no sense.

I'm going to go back and read things, gimme a while.

[notquitethere]

4mask

NQT: Erm... what?  That logic used for voting me is troll logic at best, and makes absolutely no sense.

I was asking an unnecessarily leading question but my vote isn't a troll move. I'd like answers to my questions.

Tawa, OK, I'll read back through and give you a list.

[Loud Whispers]

Loud Whispers
Did I miss your answer to this somewhere?

I think I just missed your question

The stats aren't everything but they're a very good starting point. These aren't 'superstitions': I have trawled through dozens of games looking at common patterns: the person with the most posts is very very rarely scum. This makes sense as scum player most often play reactively.

Fallacy was voted for every other player except me. Do you think I'm his buddy? If not, then who was bussing him?

I do not think you are his buddy, and I don't know what bussing is so I can't say.

Everybody: Can each of you please make two lists; one for who you think is scum, from most likely to least likely, and who you think is playing the best, from most likely to least likely? Discounting Grak and HLG, of course.

Spoiler: least likely to most likely scum (click to show/hide)

Tawarochir
notquitethere
4maskwolf
H4zardZ1
Urist McCoder
FallacyofUrist

Spoiler: playing best to playing worst (click to show/hide)

Tawarochir
notquitethere
4maskwolf
H4zardZ1
Urist McCoder
FallacyofUrist

It's just the same as my other list

[notquitethere]

I do not think you are his buddy, and I don't know what bussing is so I can't say.

Bussing is when one scum player votes for (with the intent of lynching) another member of their team. I'm saying everyone has voted for Fallacy, so if Fallacy is scum then which of the players voting them is also scum?

[4maskwolf]

Urrrrrrrkkkkk

Life sucks.

Replacement Request

I am truly sorry about this.

[Loud Whispers]

I do not think you are his buddy, and I don't know what bussing is so I can't say.

Bussing is when one scum player votes for (with the intent of lynching) another member of their team. I'm saying everyone has voted for Fallacy, so if Fallacy is scum then which of the players voting them is also scum?

Oh I see; I did not even think of that. Ahah, I have much to look into now.

[DoctorMcTaalik]

I've read through the thread once, and I intend to go back over it. Add me as a replacement.

(Unless you specifically need a replacement IC. I'm new to forum Mafia.)

[H4zardZ1]

I'm sort of couldn't keeping up.

[Urist McCoder]

Least to most likely scum
tawochir
NQT
loud whispers
4maskwolf
hazard1
fallacyofurist

I am still voting for you fallacyofurist, you have calmed down quite a bit. BUt that first day you really were acting like scum and not in the noobish way the hiddenleafguy was. and all that you have done pretty much the intire games is this person is scum, or I am not scum he is scum.

best to worst players
tawochir
NQT
loud whispers
fallacyofurist
4maskwolf
hazard1

[Teneb]

I'm extending the day to 21:00 BRT (GMT-3) today. That's 8 and a half hours from now. 4maskwolf's request noted.

[FallacyofUrist]

Spoiler: compressed Urist McCoder (click to show/hide)

Least to most likely scum
tawochir
NQT
loud whispers
4maskwolf
hazard1
fallacyofurist

I am still voting for you fallacyofurist, you have calmed down quite a bit. BUt that first day you really were acting like scum and not in the noobish way the hiddenleafguy was. and all that you have done pretty much the intire games is this person is scum, or I am not scum he is scum.

best to worst players
tawochir
NQT
loud whispers
fallacyofurist
4maskwolf
hazard1

Two things.
One: you think I'm a better player than one of the ICs? I'm flattered. But your perceptions are off. You can tell I'm not very good at this game, yet you place me above 4maskwolf. Also, I'm curious why you put tawarochir at the top of your "best to worst players list". To me, he seems rather... average in playing abilities, Loud Whispers and NQT are clearly more skilled than him(or at least they're putting in more effort). Would you care to explain why you think tawarochir is better than Loud Whispers?
Two: translated into proper grammar: "All that you have done for this entire game is basically this: 'this person is scum, or I am not scum, he is scum'." Hm. So you're saying that my attacks are bland? Okay, let's bring down the hammer.

Urist McCoder.

I have a lot of posts to quote.
(Let's hope I can follow up on this.)
By the way, I think that bad grammar is a scumtell. Proof: a player who puts less effort into the game, more passive, copies other arguments, those are scumtells. More active players are less likely to be scum. If someone puts less effort into their posts(anybody can apply better grammar and spelling), its a sign they care less about their attacks/defenses. Thus, scum. Probably wrong, but a good theory in my perspective.

Also, here's some food for thought for everybody: if I really am scum, then who is my partner?

[Tawa]

Fallacy: Why didn't you make a list?

[FallacyofUrist]

Fallacy: Why didn't you make a list?

A list of what, partner probabilities?

[Urist McCoder]

I think you are better than 4maskwolf because he is basically lurking, while even though you are coming across as scummy at least you aren't lurking. which I think is better.

[FallacyofUrist]

Graaghh...
You think its better to be scummy than lurk?