Scripten: Frostmoon: First of all, apologies for not looking up your gender. My bad, there. As far as Illgeo goes, he is fairly scummy, but it's hard to tell with the way that BlitzDungeoneer is playing. If he [Blitz], is town, then my first target would be Illgeo, since a lot of my suspicion for Deathsword is from the way BlitzDungeoneer is acting toward him. You are right that Deathsword's most recent post does change my opinion a bit, but I am definitely keeping my FoS on him. As for Gulddom, his flip gave next to no information to me. I thought he was most likely town to begin with and I will admit that choosing him left very little trace back to scum.
Don't worry about the gender thing; I was expecting someone to slip up on it. :3 Why did you believe that Gulddom was (most likely) town before he was nightkilled?
anailater:PFP
Frostmoon: To explain my shortness : My laptop is currently dead, and as such I've been posting from my phone, which as mentioned above really sucks, so it's quite hard to write full length posts, but I'll try to write abit more.
To explain my quietness: No one was addressing questions to me at the time so I wasn't posting much, but I have been reading, so I'm aware of the allegations towards Blitz and Deathsword.
It's fine. :3 A high suggestion, though, is to ask other people questions, even if they're generic. Anyway, I noticed that your reads didn't include Deathsword. What's your opinion on him? Does yobbo still feel at all scummy to you? Could you please explain your section on Illgeo? What do you find weird about Scripten's interactions with me?
Illgeo:Frostmoon:Hard to say.
Blitz looks scum or very newbie town.
You and Deathswors look townish.
Hard to say about others.
Why does Blitz look like scum/newbie town? Why do I look townish? Why does Deathsword, whom certain people believe might be scum, look townish to you? Does the rest of the group fall under neutral/null?
yobbo:Yes, when it comes to anailater all i really have against him is Nerjin's opinion, which i'm giving more weight to now that i know Nerjin was definitely town. I'm still pretty convinced by the results of my initial attack (on anailater).
As for how Scripten is directing suspicions… i don't even know. I read back over his recent posts to try to figure out what gave me that feeling, but there's nothing i can point to. It's just a really persistent feeling. I don't think it's enough to go on at all. And i think it could be just that he's trying to get people to be active by saying things like "being active is good for town", and that gives me the feeling that he's also saying "so those who aren't must be scum, hinthint". But it's true that being active is good for town, and important to say it, especially now. I feel silly even typing this all out -.-
Your initial attack on anailater? What makes you feel so confident about it's results? Also, your paragraph on Scripten is not silly. Anything-and I mean anything-that you find suspicious should be noted mentally, even if it mostly consists of gut feeling. Besides, your gut isn't the only one that seems to hate Scripten; using only that, I'd also be fingering him.
Nerjin:Some shtuff about quoting people.
Got it. I've also seen "Snip" used in place of a full quote.
Blitz: Well, like I said, I don't think Deathsword is scum, all things considered. Even if he hasn't posted much, his posts have a high level and quality of content, he has given valid reasons for not being able to posts, some of which I'm able to confirm, particularly the touchscreen issue. I don't have any other reads, though, mostly because I'm shit at reading people's intentions over the internet.
Thanks for the info on lurking and active-lurking, by the way.
You're welcome about the info. :3 However, why focus on Deathsword in that paragraph? How does yobbo, who you later say is scummier than anailater, compare to Deathsword?
So...
I'm out of the game so soon? Meh.
Before I go, I want to say;
It's been fun guys, and I can see why some enjoy it. I did I this game. I wonder if I should even post for the rest of the game... Not like it would make a difference. This post probably marks me as scummy in everybody else's minds as it is.
You still have quite a few more hours to prove yourself, and if I were you, I'd post. Bleh. Scripten ninja'd me. Well, if you believe that anyone's scummy or townish, post about it! Information is always useful. Anyway, I'm happy that you enjoyed this game of mafia. :3