Hey guys, sorry I haven't been around.
To TDS and Jack: The main suspicion on me, that of voting borno and not tn is understandable, but I addressed it when I made the suspicious statements and votes. I said that tn is behaving scummy, as in giving up, lashing out etc, but that could just be the signs of not understanding our game play. In addition to that, I agree with 4maskwolf's policy of not lynching new players (judging on their game play) on the first day. I also thought that having a destabilizing force to the discussions, such as a hot-head or person with different play style would encourage discussion and would help us find scum.
Anyway, if I was mafia, the only reason I can think of for me to distance myself from tn and not vote him would be if he was mafia. He
is was town, and so I think that point is kind of moot.
Jack A T As for borno's questions, here are the answers
Most of my questions on borno were just to put pressure on, and to tell the truth, I had just jumped in and replaced and I thought borno was the most likely candidate. He reminds me a lot of myself when scum, refusing to rise to bait and calmly refuting evidence, but restating himself and not hunting other people because he is too busy defending himself.
Most of his points on me were just him wondering about my views on him and tn. This is understandable, but I think I explained it here.
Borno seems to me like a fairly experienced player playing scum.
tn5421 seems to me like a rather twitchy player, possibly indicating scum, but more likely indicating unfamiliarity with this forum's playstyle. In any case, he will be useful to stir things up and get reactions, just like I was in my first game.
and here
I agree that he is probably mafia, but I he is typical of depressed new player under fire as exemplified in Kingmaker IV.
I said that borno's vote on tn was useless because tn just gave up. He wouldn't respond to the vote. So borno's vote would probably be more telling elsewhere.
Jack A T
I thought this was going to be a strong scum lean, but then I read through your posts, so you're leaning town.
TDS This is confusing, you say you were incredibly suspicious of Jack,
before you read his posts? I dunno, this seems a bit suspect. Could just be a slip of the tongue, is that right? Or is there more here?
KansaTo LARD: Honestly because I'm not entirely sure who is and who isn't mafia at this point, I probably should have cast a vote earlier on to add pressure to somebody but as we are really close to the end now it wouldn't do anything.
I would probably wait for them to slip up and contradict something or do something that makes them seem suspicious, I'm not really sure what questions to ask to make them slip up though. As for the actual method of that I would probably as them a question to clarify the part that contradicted something else or made them suspicious in my eyes.
This doesn't sit right for me. You just seem to be acting confused and unsure of yourself. That in itself is not a bad thing, but you use it as an excuse for not hunting or voting. Don't worry about that, you are far more suspicious when you sit on the fence than when you start hunting and savagely tearing people apart for their smallest verbal blunders.
Oh, and waiting for mafia to slip up and contradict themselves is something that will keep you waiting for a while. When somebody does contradict themselves, it is more often than not just an honest townie mistake.
So
Kansa, You are sitting on the fence, confused and unsure, while afraid to make a move against anybody for fear of looking suspicious. You should probably have cast your vote, it would have taken the suspicion off your head. But you didn't. And now bad things will happen.
As for reads, I have no idea who would have killed tn5421. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me.
Jack: Probably would have killed Tiruin, the other IC, not tn5421. But we did make a lot of comments how the doctor/jailkeeper should protect the IC's. Moderate town. I would like to see his opinions on Tiruin
Tiruin: Same as Jack but vice versa. Also moderate town. But I can't read experienced players very well. I would like to see her opinions on Jack.
TDS Respond to my above question. Then we'll see.
RangerCado: Scum did
exactly what you expected eh? Seems like you know a lot about what the mafia are doing
. Whatever, just post more, I need to form a better opinion of you.
Kansa: Has my vote. For above reasons.