Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ToonyMan]

Why'd you vote Elephant Parade over NativeForeigner?

[Superblackcat]

E is earlier in the alphabet than N

[Elephant Parade]

E is earlier in the alphabet than N

What. No. That's a terrible reason. Seriously, you should have some reason for voting me over NF. Unless, of course, you're scum and don't actually have a reason to vote either of us.

Superblackcat: What are your reads? Do you think NF is scummy, or just busy?

[NativeForeigner]

E is earlier in the alphabet than N

You're kidding, right?

[makeinu]

E is earlier in the alphabet than N

You're kidding, right?

Dude. That's not even flipping a coin random. That's not even trying. Seriously? A random vote, utterly random, at MyLo?

NativeForeigner - "I agree with Makeinu, Scientist is really suspicious!"  I don't think Makeinu is scum, but I find his suspicions of Scientist as completely paranoid since it's only possible if one of the four vanilla townies is hiding their role for no reason whatsoever.  I will not allow a Scientist lynch.  I'm guessing NF's other suspect he's concealing might be me, since outside parties might think that Scientist and I are both lying in the most cleverest ploy ever, but sadly, this is not possible.

Paranoid I might be, that I won't deny. However, I can think of a reason why a town power role might conceal himself still: if they exist, they know scientist is likely scum, or ToonyMan is, and by concealing that as a known, they stand a better chance of ferreting out the partner. If the scum-hunt turns solely on scientist, then the partner can stay hidden, and we have to start from scratch tomorrow.

Mind, I'm not saying that is what's happening, but it makes sense to me as a possibility, and it helps explain why scum didn't kill a known power role, a dangerous one or them, last night, instead apparently targeting the other.

As to what targeting you last night means, I don't know, but it veers wildly into WIFOM territory if I start considering what it means regarding EP. Like, I can't even comprehend what they may have been thinking.

So, all things considered, I won't rule out scientist as scum as a possibility. Sometimes numbers do lie, if you don't know all the variables.

If we assume scum wouldn't bus at this point, which is logical, and with no solid case in any event, we can make some guesses.

[Elephant Parade]

E is earlier in the alphabet than N

What. No. That's a terrible reason. Seriously, you should have some reason for voting me over NF. Unless, of course, you're scum and don't actually have a reason to vote either of us.

Superblackcat: What are your reads? Do you think NF is scummy, or just busy?

Also, if you're going to vote me over somebody else for no actual reason, you need to at least ask some questions. This isn't the time for random votes.

[ToonyMan]

@Makeinu:
Hmm, you make a good point.  NativeForeigner may want a Scientist lynch because he is in fact hiding his role.  And PufferFish/Scientist not making an action Night 1 is pretty suspect.

However, I'm not going to vote Scientist unless NF's explicitly states this.  That way, if we lynch Scientist and he actually is town Jailkeeper, NF is lying and I can shoot him.  But if we keep things implied I can't consider that enough to shoot.


@Superblackcat:

E is earlier in the alphabet than N

That's pretty silly, but I can see why'd you say that since if you believe what I'm saying it doesn't matter whether it's Elephant Parade or Nativeforeigner, they would be both scum to you.

Still, it's nice to give reasons.  However, a bit early you say this, which sort of implies that you think NativeForeigner is town, what are your thoughts now?  Also, Superblackcat for now.

[NativeForeigner]

@Makeinu:
Hmm, you make a good point.  NativeForeigner may want a Scientist lynch because he is in fact hiding his role.  And PufferFish/Scientist not making an action Night 1 is pretty suspect.

However, I'm not going to vote Scientist unless NF's explicitly states this.  That way, if we lynch Scientist and he actually is town Jailkeeper, NF is lying and I can shoot him.  But if we keep things implied I can't consider that enough to shoot.

As much as I'd love to say that and have this in the bag, I'm not hiding a power role. Not gonna lie and say otherwise for a scientist lynch because that only hurts town if he's somehow the jailkeeper.

[makeinu]

Yeah, that was more hopeful than anything else. After Tiruin's SK flip, I'm a little jumpy, I think, and overthinking things.

[Toaster]

Vote Count:

Elephant Parade: Superblackcat
Superblackcat: makeinu, Elephant Parade, ToonyMan
+!!scientist!!+:
makeinu:
ToonyMan:
NativeForeigner:

No Lynch:

Not Voting: +!!scientist!!+, NativeForeigner


Day 4 will last until Monday, 2/3 at 11 PM EST, about 7 1/4 hours from now.

[ToonyMan]

I'm worried, the other mafia player isn't voting to save his buddy if SBC is mafia.  Can you reply to my previous post SBC?

[NativeForeigner]

I'm asking now if anyone would like my extension used to extend this day. I'll check again about an hour before day end. If no one speaks up, I'm letting the day end. Either way, I'll likely be coming back to vote SBC depending on how/if he responds.

[ToonyMan]

I don't mind a SBC lynch.

If SBC flips mafia I am not shooting tonight.  Scientist, you can do whatever.  I would advice blocking somebody you think is scum though.

If SBC flips town I'm going to shoot Elephant Parade.  Scientist, you block NativeForeigner or Makeinu.  I say either or because if NF and Makeinu are the scum team then they'll kill with the player you aren't blocking.  Don't state who you are blocking.

If you see any problems with this plan you can speak up.  I'll also consider shooting NativeForeigner instead and have you choose between Elephant Parade or Makeinu if you want to.

[Elephant Parade]

Well, the plan makes sense. Obviously, I think that you should shoot NF, since if you don't it's a town loss (unless scientist blocks/protects correctly, of course). Then again, NF will say the same thing.

So really, it's up to you. I recommend that you take this time to ask us some questions, so that you are more likely to hit the correct target.

Also, NF, you need to use your extend.

Hopefully, SBC is scum and none of this matters.

[makeinu]

Definitely Extend. We don't have a second chance at this, even with a Vig and a Jailkeeper.