TiruinPPE:
1. What are you talking about "ellipsis'd"?
That paragraph about your questions regarding the standardism of the game. What use is that?
Did you mean eclipsed by any chance?
Zombie Urist:
Okay, not that I'm not hunting Ranger, I've enough time to go through both posts. I apologize for anything I answer twice.
[1]No one in the past ever had a problem with the numbering system.
[2]The Soldier and counting is a running gag from Roguelike 6.
[3]Already addressed the numbers stuff.
[4]That's not how scumhunting works. Why would I want to eliminate town? I'm going to eliminate scum by lynching them, regardless of pressure and other BS. Who have you eliminated as town?
[5] Meh.
[6] Its funny how you think numbering is hard to read and then you start numbering.
[7] Yes. I have no reads on those with no null reads, but I'm fairly confident on my Tiruin read. There is a difference between a "neutral read" and a "null read".
[8] I am not refusing to develop a case on Tiruin. Don't know what you mean by outlasting. Ok.
[9] Why are you answering for her? How do you know what she means?
[10] I don't have any more information that I'm not sharing and claiming I do is a "wild accusation".
Re-Numbered so we can communicate without confusion
1 - When I have to read your post four times to figure out what you're commenting on, it annoys me and makes it so I can't be sure that I am answering the right questions.
2 - Chalk it up to an in-joke I didn't know I guess.
3 - Ditto
4 - I think this was answered already.
5 - Glad to know you care about my opinion.
6 - In that case it made it easy to read. First rule of thumb is other people have to read and understand what you're saying.
7 - I think your read is rubbish. Why do you not care about making sure you have reads on ALL the people?
8 - You case hasn't moved beyond what you started the day with. Or if it has I don't know where. Answered the question in post to Tiruin.
9 - Because your question was on pedantics and hopefully my answer cleared confusion between the two of you.
10- Also answered in my post to Tiruin.
-snip-
All of them basically. I also find it strange that the other two people who can confirm your lover ability haven't done so. Also Vector claims to have no-actioned. So the other claim is kinda iffy too. Maybe cuz your scum.
Oh yay last sentence
Maybe cuz he's scum. What are you doing about it?
Asking questions.
Count the questions in your quote please.
I countered all of Griffon's arguments.
Except not in such a way that they're able to be read as answers to my arguments. And of course any that you don't want to answer such as your thoughts on DS. Countered is a bit strong really, but at least you responded to them all. Probably, not really sure as I cant read your posts.
-snip-
Who else besides Ranger have you eliminated? Please give reads on Hapah, NQT, Zrk2, and Tiruin.
Ok. Why were you answering for Tiruin?
Rolefishing.
Please define noncommittal.
NQT, Toaster and Sheep for now. Eliminated might be too strong, but they're all fairly solid town reads to me.
NQT I'm basing most of my trust on him on Ranger, plus there's the fact that he seems to be basing most of his game around his abilities which reads as someone infatuated with his abilities, but not a scum.
Hapah I like the guy, and would feel hurt if he wasn't town. His play seems solid and he seems to read an communicate himself well.
Zrk2 Leaning toward scum. I don't like some of his actions, but they were all poked at by other folk for now so I'm waiting for him to respond so I can get more of a read.
Tiruin Leaning town. Seeing as I actually can understand her posts (a skill you seem to lack in your tunnel) I can see most of where her suspicions and reads came from and I tend to agree. So seeing as I'm town and she's reading the same people as I, I'm thinking she's town
I must ask, why are you asking so many people for our reads on Tiruin? It sounds like you're trying to get our approval.
They posted while I was writing the other post. I went to dinner and just got back.
So... Thoughts on the subject?