Look more carefully. >_> Basically he's been contradicting himself a lot and when I call him out on it, he just goes "you're stupid" and dismisses my argument.
Or, you're saying things that make no sense to me whatsoever and/or are hilariously stupid, and I'm calling them stupid because that's what they are. Where do I contradict myself a lot? Where do I simply dismiss your arguments as stupid and not attempt to explain them at all? Where's your evidence?
So I looked it up.
Or, I read the OP, received my role, and came to the logical conclusion that the Mafia would have damaging abilities. Because they're Mafia and they need to kill us. Did you have any reason to believe that they didn't have any damaging abilities whatsoever?
Have some context: Toaster's accusing me of knowing that the scum have no mafiakill(this is before Dariush said that they did not) because I'm scum. I respond with my reasons for thinking this - the OP states that there's an HP system, and I assume that the scum will have damaging abilities. I then ask Toaster if he had a reason to think that there were no damaging abilities on the scumteam.
Where's the Burden of Proof fallacy committed? I don't see it. The burden is on Toaster to prove that I'm scum.
Hm. Just because you don't say it in that post doesn't negate the fact that you state the mafia don't have a traditional NK.
Does the word 'time' ring any bells? Mean anything to you at all? At the time of the post I was referring to, the one that Toaster was accusing me of being scum for, I had not said that. That is the whole point of that statement that went way over your head for some mysterious reason. There are other factors that make my later mention of the lack of a mafiakill non-scummy(the mod saying it, stated reasons for me to believe that the scum have no NK).
Maybe you should answer the accusation instead of dismissing it? I think this is a good point to bring up.
Yes, the element of guessing changes it. Not enough to change the result; either the scum knows how much HP each townie has, or they know how much HP each townie has lost and can, either way, target people they think will die when targeted with a damaging ability.
Just admit that everything I've said is true since you don't seem to want to dispute it and instead try shrug it off.
That's the crux of my case. You haven't bothered to actually refute any of these points.
All of these points that add up to...what, exactly?
Furthermore, you're tunneling.
Hahaha, no. That's false.
I have FOS'd Toaster and Imiknorris while investigating them for pressure. I have also voted for Shakerag. Please make sure you're right before spouting stupid bullshit, thanks.
Orangebottle's Guide to Arguing.
1. Call opposition's arguments stupid without explaining.
2. Insult the opposition.
3. Use big letters.
Zombie Urist's Guide to Mafia:
1. Refuge in Audacity(that's what RiA means) whenever possible.
2. Be a massive hypocrite.
PPE:
Imiknorris:
OB:
...It sounded better that way in my head.
Basically, the scum already know who's scum, so paying attention to each and every tiny little detail of every post is less critical to their success than it would be if they were town.
My experience as scum suggests otherwise. If anything, I needed to pay more attention to catch mistakes and tells that I knew were false positives.
Huh. It's the opposite for me.