UnvoteZombie:
Orangebottle:
Also, the mere existence of a damage/health system implies the lack of a mafiakill.
Why? Explain.
Because it makes no sense to implement some complicated health/damage system when the scum can just instantly kill anyone every night. Did that really need explaining?
It give me insight into the way you play; It's basically asking you,"Would you prefer to be a doctor, watcher, or vigilante, and why?" Even though the roles aren't quite as clear-cut as that, there are still some things I can deduce from the information.
Please share this insight.
Well, for one, he does
not prefer taking direct action against his suspicions at night, meaning he likely has a stronger day game.
I don't play LoL so I'm not familiar with the champions. So how would a non-LoL player know about the doctor/watcher/vig thing?
By doing what Tiruin did, and looking it up. It's not that hard.
You know, just to stop the HP claim theory, I'm going to claim I have 4 HP.
That's incredibly stupid. As town, you've opened yourself up to the scum planning on taking you out. As scum, you've done an incredible flub by making it easier for the town to kill you. The only ways I can see this possibly being beneficial to you is:
A) It stops discussion(and you're scum).
B) It encourages everyone to claim their HP(and you're scum).
C) Nobody's scumhunting because of the claim theory and it stops discussion of said theory(maybe town?).
C clearly hasn't happened. Why'd you do it,
Zombie?
Irony:
For starters, either they're going to know about that damage because they caused it, or low-health targets will hopefully be suspicious targets anyway. I don't see perfect knowledge of town-inflicted damage being the key to a scum victory, unless you think healing will make that much of a difference.
Suspicious targets that are town are still town. The more people scum can take out in one night, the better, and the information helps them plan that out.
More importantly, "it helps the scumteam" isn't what you said. "It's identical to listing the precise damage needed to kill everyone" is what you said, and that clearly isn't the case here.
Listing the precise damage needed to kill everyone helps the scumteam target their damage abilities.
Listing the precise damage everyone already took helps the scumteam target their damage abilities.
I'm not seeing much of a difference there.
PPE:
Shakerag:
In reference to early mass claim and Bookthras, seems like most of the talk came out of BSER. An example. After going back and re-reading said discussion, I grant that Bookthras was more talking about proposing an early claim, not talking about massclaiming early. Such is my memory. However, having said that, I still find it suspicious that you're getting people to think about (and possibly agree on) what info to massclaim later. What benefit is there to talking about claiming HP totals now as opposed to later on when a massclaim is called for?
OB: See above. Feels like Toaster is trying to see what info everyone wants/is willing to share so as to better craft a fakeclaim for later.
I see. That makes a bit more sense.