Blarg... I've got a problem. I have an electric oven. It sits on the countertop but it's not a toaster oven. It's pretty large and it works brilliantly. It's also getting a bit old - a friend gave it to me 4 years ago and it was already old then. And dirty. I put some effort into cleaning it up but it will never look new at this point.
Recently I decided to try to at least get the trays to be cleaner. Normal soap wouldn't get all the residue from years of cooking off the trays, so I used a much stronger cleaner recommended to me by a friend. The cleaner,
Savo Razant, has warning labels all over it. You have to wear gloves to use it or it burns your skin a little bit (and I did learn that the hard way). I had used it successfully to clean my shower, toilet, and sink really well, so stupidly I thought it would be a good choice for getting the caked-on gunk off my oven trays.
Turns out it may have worked a little too well. Trying to cook with the oven after I had cleaned the trays, I noticed a funny taste in some of my food. I also noticed some gunk on the tray after cooking which I assumed was grease and oil from the cooking. When I finally got around to trying to wash it, I realized it was actually really sticky, like some kind of resin. I think it's the non-stick coating on the trays. The cleaner must have interacted with it so now when it's heated, it liquifies and gets into my food.
Is there anything I can do about this? It's definitely not possible to buy new trays for this oven (it's an unusual size and very old) and buying a new oven would obviously be very expensive (and it seems a bit silly, considering this one works fine). I suppose I can put aluminum foil on the trays, but that scrapes off easily when cooking something I need to flip (like fries, etc.) and I'd hate to get little bits of aluminum in my food... I'm tempted to keep scrubbing with the harsh cleaner until all the nonstick stuff just comes all the way off, but I'm not sure if that would work... Any ideas?