Damnit, I'm an idiot for overthinking this game.
All of these roles are guaranteed to be in-game:
Devil (Leafsnail)
Fortune Teller (MaxWhite)
Warlock (ECrownOfFire)
Guard (Toaster)
Priest (Solifuge)
Priest (JoshuaFH)
IronyOwl (Witch)
These are the -only- roles that might not be in-game:
Knight (Bdthemag)
Guardian Angel (MBP)
Sexton (NativeForiegner)
The Scumteam HAVE to condemn Toaster, and the only surviving person to know that guarding happened, or else they'll be caught among the only possible falseclaims. Also, if anyone attached to one of the Guaranteed To Be In-Game roles is actually the Vamp. Lord, one of Bdthemag, MBP, or Native have to be scum, and have to be the one who actually has the role, which they let their Lord falseclaim.
Of course, taking the simpler possibility, the Lord is one of Bdthemag, MBP, or Native. Unvote.
Crown, your bias is palpable. I'm not chainsawing Toaster, I'm stating a fact! I was guarded, as were other players who supported this. The players who supported this claim WERE NOT ALWAYS SCUM, and may well have stated they were guarded before conversion... this is something I'm trying to resolve right now. Given the above, either Toaster IS the Guard, or the real guard is a Cultist with him, and one of MBP, Native, or Bdthemag.
Do you not find it immensely less likely that Toaster is Scum, given that he'd have to have been consistently killing off his own team, and TRYING to reveal that the Scum Team was actually a Cult, when he could have slid on by? This makes no sense at all!
Everyone, stop reflexively condemning people based on the arguments of others, and THINK FOR YOURSELF for a damned second!